You are missing the point as well. If you want your guild to be on that specific realm YES you have to create a new guild there. The point is that if you want to have your guild that you have been in and built up over the years on transferred to that realm for reasons other than recruiting purposes or whatever (whether you think it’s significant or not) can’t happen and that is the reason of the post again… YOU may think that just starting a guild on a whim is just fine. I don’t as well as many others that have created guilds with history, achievements etc etc etc. It makes a difference to those that have put time and effort into things all of these years and don’t want it just thrown away.