Agreed. That’s going to definitely change how things are played.
We have more solo content available now.
I think if an entire guild of four people are completing these raids, it should count.
I’d definitely sign a petition for that.
Offer still stands. I can move a toon into your guild to finish the achievement and leave. My husband would have no problem doing that as well.
So my guild just did ICC Heroic 25, and sure my sons and my wife got the mount but the guild achievement for it didnt count. It just sucks is all. While other people wil ltell me to recruit more etc. I have my reasons listed above on why I refuse to do that. i feel like older content should require only 4 memberes in aguild to complete it or maybe even 2. My wife and I cimpleted half of ICC 25 man heroic ourselves before inviting my sons and doing the whole thing with them on alts.
are you a guild though? really? Doesn’t a guild charter still require 5 signatures? you may be one in name, but not in the eye of blizz.
they didn’t claim to be on the raid team, just a member of the guild 
I was on the raid team that matched up to my work schedule as my rogue. As a bystander and normal member, I saw plenty of drama in that guild, and every guild for the past 28 years straight.