Well yeah i forgot about the one person making the charter but you need 4 signatures. So yes totall of 5
I think it was pointed out already, but the guild achievements are pretty old. They are based on having a guild do them on current, non trivialized content. They do require a number, for 10-content itâs lower than 13, 25-content is 13.
There is the strange condition where some of the guild rewards are for items like a Dark Phoenix pet that people might like to have with trivial content.
Should be weighed in by Blizzard someday. New feature 7861237861234.
For guild achievements of raids, size requires 80% of the group to be members of the guild, and itâs 80% of the group capacity for the mode.
For ICC 25, 80% would be 20 people, for 10 man itâd be 8. For anything thatâs Flex, which i think is Legion onwards, it would require 8 people.
True, and I agree that curent content should require the 80% of groups. However trivial content of the past shouldnt is my point.
2 Likes
What if I disagreed and said I think itâs ok for achieves not to be available?
But you donât have to convince me, Blizzard would need to change. Iâm ok if they do.
I feel like people give up before they even try when they use that âeveryone is too mean and toxicâ reasoning.
Like yeah, itâs been like this since the dawn of humanityâŚ
I joined a guild on an alt to buy all the rewards because my guild will never unlock them due to the rediclious requirements for old raids to be considered a âguild groupâ.
I was apart of the 2nd best raiding guiild in BC on my server at the time. I ran a raiding guild in all of WOTLK and was harassed through almost that entire expansion. I ran a guild in final fantasy of 512 members for what 3 years? I know the drama and chaos that happens when you get more and more people in a group. Too many people with disagreements etc as well as people being jealous of others in a video game.
My wife only plays to do things with the family, no one else and I personally wouldnt want her to have to deal with that or people in groups with the whole (Herp derp dps sucks blah blah blah). Heck she even refuses to even get a DPS meter or addons. Currently im using one addon to find TLPD.
it just would be nice if blizzard allows smaller guilds such as my own to also get achievemnts for completing stuff as we are a full group.
2 Likes
The easiest solution would be to just have 21 more kids and then you will have enoughâŚproblem solved.
Im good, 2 is more then enough lol.
1 Like
This is a red flag for me. Iâll match your anecdote with mine: every guild or Discord Iâve ever been in, whenever I hear some dude be like, âI was in a world first guild, I was in the best guild on the server, I was in a top 100 world guildâ
I know I am being fed absolute drivel from what is statistically going to be a cringe lord. The people who say that are almost always cringe lords.
So Iâm guessing that had something to do with the harassment.
The harassment was due to a person being removed from my guild due to sexually harassing a few female guild members of mine. He left, made new guild and got members to join him on the server, and thus the harassment of me happened all throughout Wotlk because I was the one who removed him. As far as me saying I was in the 2nd best raiding guild on my server, they were the guild to kill all of the bosses in BC second behind the first. They had 4 seperate raid groups and schedules. That experience I was just a bystander but witnessed countless problems between members and officers/the guild leader in the amount of time I was in it. The drama and bullcrap I witnessed, was the entire reason I decided to make my own guild in WOTLK and raid that way.
I have no idea what a cringe lord is. All I know is that by being a normal member as well as a guild leader since 1997 until now, I have seen too much chaos and such erupt with many players. I have witnessed and have had to get into the middle of that stuff as a guild leader, that I will never want to put my wife through that or my kids. I am sorry but I take my 28 years of striaght MMORPG playing over someone over the internet. A lot of that time I was quiet and just did raids or dungeons and didnt make waves with other people. However witnessing those waves made by othres confirms drama happens, a hell of a lot. Drama, I personally want to avoid which means, avoiding people who have a propensity of causing it. Hence why I avoid raids except LFR like the plague.
I have helped several couples create their own guild and then leave. This is not out of the ordinary. Many people have bank guilds and alt guilds.
1 Like
The rewards are ok but no one should have to do this over trivial content that isnt current. The avhievements are what my kids and wife want to do but we cant because wea re locked out, which sucks. If they would lower the stupid guild group % for older content it would be good for us to have something to work towards. They may not matter to others but they matter to us and it would give us stuff to work towards.
2 Likes
What ridiculous requirements?
Raids require 8-12 people to complete for the achievements.
Dungeons require 3 people to get those achievements.
Rep requirements for the stay classy achievements are probably the most annoying, but not even remotely bad.
So, honestlyâŚwhat requirements are ridiculous?
My guild is very unorganized and mostly solo players. Getting 8-12 people to go clear MC is not going to happen. However, if it was something like 3 me and my two buddies could get it done.
1 Like
I know the feeling. I left a guild that was wholly unorganized. I havenât asked this current guild if we plan on doing older guild achievements. Iâd like to. I collect, so itâs annoying knowing that I donât have all the guild stuff.
Btw, I wasnât trying to be argumentative. I really appreciate your answer.
1 Like
Trivial content such as ICC heroic was completed by four people all in the same guild. There is no reason why older content needs to have the same guild group requirement as current content. A guild of 4 people should have gotten the guild achievement for it.
Im newer so if it gives gold or something, maybe take that away and just give the achievemnt for those completing it in a guild but not at the required guild group level. Something like that.
2 Likes
Completely agree. If itâs soloableâŚit shouldnât matter.
1 Like
Current content yes, keep the guild group requirements. Older content, that should be lowered to 2-4 people is my point. IMHO guilds and their achievements should be totally revamped up to current with player housing coming along.
1 Like