Guild Bank Missing Items Bug -- Aug/Sept 2024

In case you are wondering why so many think they could have restored more, but didn’t. Here is why:

The bug appeared at a certain point in time, everything there, then not. The gbank log stopped at that point, meaning all items were accounted for as going in, but none were withdrawn, they poofed without any notation on the log. It seemed pretty straight-forward just to look at any snapshot of the deposits previous and note anything that was missing without a withdrawal notation.

Trusting the company, we went through the proper channels to get this acknowledged and fixed. Our thread grew and we saw the bug listed in open items. All seemed to be going okay and we were alarmed, but had no doubt it would be fixed.

Then the bug was closed as fixed, but no notification was sent to the thread that we were all sent from CS to create. The CS tickets all pretty much said the same, “CS can’t help with this, go to the bug forum”. We started to worry, but still figured such a trusted company would handle it, or perhaps overlooked something. We started to re-escalate CS tickets, and emotions started to elevate. The thread kept growing with more and more people noticing the problem. Thousands of posts. People began getting more urgent in their please for some notification or clarification in the bug forum.

3-4 weeks later with people commiserating daily about what could be going on, sharing any snippets they received from their CS tickets in hopes to spread whatever info we could get (it was contradictory, but we stayed hopeful). We didn’t know whether to touch our gbanks or not, some CS tickets said we could, some said not to. People started to feel very ignored and emotional at the lack of any clarification as to what was going on. We knew it was acknowledged, being investigated, then closed. We had no idea it was still under investigation until we were made aware of the French forum blue post.

The French post, said they were still investigating the issue of missing items. We still had nothing past the bug closure on the US forums, but it gave us hope.

People doubled down on requesting any official status on the US Bug Forum. This is when things got a bit catty with the message that we had not been ignored. Yes, we have been ignored. We have been sitting for weeks sharing info and CS snippets in order to stay hopeful and finally found the first shred of any info that they were still working on getting our stuff back, by accident!!! Yes, we were ignored. If you actively send everyone with this problem to a single location (over 500 people with over 800 banks mentioned), then never notify anything there or in the open issue/bug report, you ARE ignoring them.

Fast forward, and we see this post from Linxy, not on the bug forum where we were all sitting every day…on the general forum as new update. This is the first official US notification and it says: sorry, thx bai!

This is why we are pissed. This is why people quit, unsubbed, got refunds for TWW, etc.

Everything we have been told is contradictory, vague, and borderline untruthful. Its under investigation, then closed. It’s okay to use your gbank, don’t use your gbank. We are sending you back your items, BOE bags were originally sent BOP, all items with charges have 0 charges, some items sell price reduced to 1copper. “Incomplete restoration for some guilds” = barely complete restoration for ALL guilds.

No armor, weapons, mogs, toys, pre-launch expansion flair items (haunted memento, etc) , mounts, pets, gold, could be returned. No grey keepsake or personal letters were returned.

After waiting so long and then finding some hope after stumbling on the French post, we are greeted to this faceless, issue diminishing message on the General forum. Not being part of this issue and reading that, you would think that we waited a while, but got most everything returned. That this would be a welcome resolution to this “ongoing” issue.

That is NOT what happened.

40 Likes

I got one recipe back. I lost 6 tabs of pets
LEVEL 25s and 1 tab of Xmas recipes and about 20 stacks of riding hollys that I have been collecting for years!

The amount of time and effort and some of it just can’t be gotten back! Some of the pets are from events that won’t repeat.

I have been willing to deal and even forgive A LOT but this … THIS may send me packing.

This is very very upsetting.

16 Likes

Whenever there is unavoidable data loss, a company needs to put together a public statement that needs to be checked and rechecked. I work IT, public released statements always take longer the more likely that the data is permanently lost.

1 Like

This is very unacceptable. Who would trust them again after losing everything? No detailed statement or any attempt at being transparent.

7 Likes

How dare you rob me of my coarse stone, which I was saving for retirement.

Yeah my guild is a personal guild, though I don’t appreciate being disrespected.

3 Likes

I guarantee you that those eSports (world first) guilds are treated far better than the rest of us.

Blizzard would shut the game down for hot fixes immediately if the top eSports guilds had issues, especially the North American guilds.

They (Blizzard) loves free publicity, especially when it’s in their favour.

6 Likes

Really? Blizzard have merged access like that of the Warband system overhaul before? And you say that they have done it several times over?


Seriously, quit trolling and read what someone says rather than taking a purposefully intellectually dishonest position to garnish upvotes from forum contrarians.

A GM’s duty hasn’t changed since Vanilla, so no. “Back in the days when they had active GMs” is a lie told by trolls. GMs still act, have the same tool, and do the same things that they have always been doing.

You are just outright lying for upvotes. Quit it.

Then why are you here? Do something more meaningful with your life and learn a skill like knitting or something. That way you could make a troll rather than be a troll.

There is a specific streamer on the realm that is merged with mine, that often does things with people I raid with. According to what I was told, he did suffer loss from his personal storage guild bank, but it was only for about two days; everything came back. After that, he wiped his hands and considered it fixed. I do not know if he was told specifically not to say anything, and I have no way of verifying if this is even true; it is only coming from people who I raid with, who also do content with him. You can take that for what it’s worth.

15 Likes

Sure, I don’t doubt this.

If you’re an eSports/Streamer member of this game, Blizzard does everything possible to make you happy so that you can relay that in your streams.

15 Likes

I also want to add that, personally, I am inclined to believe what they told me due to the fact that I did not request this information. They volunteered it, knowing I had mentioned weeks ago my guild bank was missing things.

9 Likes

This is my first time posting about this issue, but I have been lurking from the start. I have been playing since 2007 and have collected many valuable items over the years, including unique and no longer obtainable items, a hoard of gemstones, and various other treasures. However, the most important items to me were the letters from friends whom I will never be able to speak with again. Unfortunately, around 95% of these items were lost from my private guild bank, and I have not received anything back at all.

I understand that the servers will eventually shut down, and if I wanted to preserve these memories, I would need to take screenshots. However, as this is a live service game that the developers intend to maintain for many years, I did not expect my items to disappear before the game’s eventual closure. We all trusted that our items would always be accessible when we needed them.

The loss of these items has made me question the security of other in-game assets, such as mounts, transmog, and even our characters. If the issue had been temporary and we had received our items back, I probably would have been able to overlook it. However, the lack of restitution for our losses is unacceptable. Additionally, my wife has not resubscribed for this expansion due to concerns about reputation loss and potential character deletion bugs.

The communication from the game developers regarding this issue has been extremely poor. As soon as I noticed the bug, I locked down my banks and refrained from adding or removing anything. However, I am uncertain if this was the correct action to take. I also refrained from submitting a ticket or posting on the forum until now, and I am worried that this may have excluded me from the list of players eligible for item restoration. The lack of clear instructions left us feeling lost and uncertain about the situation. We do not even know if there will be additional waves of item restorations or if what we have received so far is all we can expect. Furthermore, the fact that this significant issue was not addressed by the WoW media gives the impression that Blizzard did not want it to be widely discussed.

Despite the occasional shortcomings in gameplay and story, I have a deep attachment to Warcraft. My wife and I initially bonded over our shared love for the game, and I have played every expansion on and off. I intend to continue playing until the end of this Saga, but if this issue is not adequately resolved or addressed, The Last Titan might be the end of my Warcraft journey.

29 Likes

You know it might be a good time for guild leaders and owners of private guild banks to start taking Screen shots of what is in their banks now and save those files onto a usb stick storage device in case this BS happens again…Keep the files off your computer or send them to a cloud storage off your system…think I am going to go get me a usb stick and start put screen shots of all my guild banks and my personal banks now. At least with screen shots you can show blizzard in a ticket file the stuff you had that you lost…

3 Likes

I logged in today to seven mails from Blizzard regarding lost items from the gbank. What I got? 50 silk cloth, 135 mageweave, 428 frostweave, 40 saxifrage, 4 volatile air, 27 embersilk, and 14 worg haunch. I had seven tabs full of mats and transmogs and recipes, I had the Reins of the Crimson Deathcharger in there as well, and now I have a few old world mats back, yippee /s

This is the most ridiculous “fix”. Hey sorry we lost all your items lol we don’t care to check the gbank logs that show what items were deposited, sucks to be you??? My sub expires tonight and honestly, I don’t feel like playing anymore. Certainly not paying for Blizzard to just take away the things I’ve worked for over the last few years. Unless the mail is being staggered, I just can’t justify this kind of response from such a huge company, which is a damn shame because I was enjoying TWW.

18 Likes

That’s OK. You can just send each of my guilds the equivalent amount of gold lost. I estimate that to be approximately gold cap.

19 Likes

Tell you what … give my warlock Atiesh and 10 million gold (half of the estimated value), and I’ll forget this ever happened.

5 Likes

How long should we wait till we know that our guild is part of the incomplete restoration?

6 Likes

This information would be great to have.

2 Likes

Just adding my name to the rest. Nothing more to add that hasn’t already been said. My guild banks were just old crafting mats and such nothing of any real value, but I expected that they would be there. I’m not even angry about it.

It’s the response they gave after all this time that has me here. I was enjoying my time in TWW and looking forward to it’s progression. I’m sorry to those who lost things they valued. Your time should have been respected.

Happy 20th WoW!

6 Likes

So this is what we pay a subscription for, whoops bad luck all your items from the last 18 years are gone forever with no compensation.

15 Likes

This worries me. There was the issue with restoring characters and now the guild bank? I’m afraid of what may be next.

15 Likes