the guild achievement to unlock the Recipe: Seafood Magnifique Feast requires catching 10,000 fish from pools. this is an extremely high number for guilds of only 10 people (one 10-man raid team) so therefore we’re losing out on feasts.
putting bis recipes behind massively time consuming guild achieves feels like we have to become or join a mega guild to compete
It was done back in the day, it can still be done now.
One way is to have one person at exalted join a big guild with it done already and buy the recipe and then come back.
But you still have to fish up the fish to make the feasts, so why not just fish in the pools? I noticed plenty of pools as I was leveling, took a minute to fish and add 5 more to to tally. And then of course there’s the fish finder book to help even more. If everyone did this, it wouldn’t take long at all. There’s plenty of time before raids are open, and even then, cooking up individual foods is no big deal for a while.
Additionally, you can get a casual player who loves doing that kind of thing.
So… What you’re saying is… You don’t have 10 dedicated fishermen? You should rename your guild to the Gorden Fishermen and instead of raiding 10 mans the first month you raid fishing holes and lakes and oceans…
Its definitely do able by a small guild. I agree with the comment above a small guild of 10 or more can easily have it unlocked in 10 days. My guild is currently 2k away we’ve only been fishing for 7 days. We should have it unlocked before first raid.
the achievement is not really that hard to get my guild got it during the pre-patch. All my gm had us do was each raid member caught 100 fish a day if they could. some got more some got less.
A smaller guild that can’t farm achievements is probably too casual for content that would be most impacted by the extra stats. The goblin bbq grill looks cooler anyways.