Yes, imagine playing an inferior version of the game with no access to addons or macros or information that was available in Vanilla. A “have fun the way i do or nobody’s having fun” argument and another person wanting to take choices away from gamers. Also gotta love how you said you want us to imagine playing Warcraft as it’s meant to be, when… we don’t really have to imagine that when it’s reality.
Yes, cause having measurements to determine on how good your doing is bad. /s
So what i’m getting here is you like the idea for… fights to take about 30 minutes long with subpar dps and etc? I get why you would like that, because it happened in the past, but that’s because the game was new at the time. Now, with 15 years of knowledge under our belts, why would they want to regress that?
That happens with every game, it used to take me weeks, maybe months to play GTA SA cause i didn’t know what to do or how to effectively use my time tricks and etc, and i was a young little lad. Now a days, that game, while still takes a lengthy amount of time, can be completed under 40 hours, quicker then last time cause i know what to do, and it’s much still just as enjoyable, even more maybe.
Or if your speed runner, 10 minutes if your found the glitch to skip you to the last mission at the beginning of the game.
You can say that again.
If you want to remove numbers from an RPG, which is important for it cause of grinding and power progression and other things, then maybe consider that RPGs aren’t for you then?
Walkthoughs and other things exist on the internet. Do you wanna get rid of the internet while your at it too just so people will fall in match lock step on how you dictate on their fun? 
You know, allow me to make a suggestion to you.
You have the option to not look at the combat logs, you have the option to not use addons, you even have the option to play as efficiently as your guild wants you to. you have the option to not look at people posting DPS meters by… leaving the chat. You have the option to ignore everything and just play your way and just have fun. Classic is about having fun atfer all, and it shouldn’t stifle on anybody’s fun.