As the editor you didn’t ask for and you also don’t want, I suggest adding a “checkmate atheists” at the end.
(Also, this is interesting. I like lore speculation)
It might have been mentioned, but for the Winter Queen to not mention anything like this, and yet still refer to Elune as sister, I think that, while a cool explanation, I think it’s still lacking a bit.
We still haven’t seen the pantheon of Light. Just order and death, right? I kind of doubt that Elune’s genesis evolved outside the pantheon of Light, but I do like speculative threads.
Incidentally Y’Shaarj has the word Sha in his name as does Mu’sha and Azshara.
Apparently A Song of the Depths suggests that Y’Shaarj’s Heart is going to be grabbed by the Harbinger for the awakening which will lead to the return of Azshara and since Chronicle mentions an Eye of C’Thun being grabbed along with us witnessing Xal’atath claiming the Hunger of Yogg-Saron…
Mu’sha is getting her Heart & Eye back along with her Hunger…
The Song of the First Ones is about the Relics of Mu’sha’s demise: The Heart(Y’Shaarj), the Eye(C’Thun), the Hunger(Yogg-Saron), the Body(Hallowfall Crystal), the Soul(Azshara) and the Tear(Xal’atath)… The 6 Gods will become the 7th(just as how the 6 Elder Dragons of Guild Wars 2 become the Dragonvoid)…
Mu’sha one of Cenarius’s mothers(Elune and Ysera are the others with Elune providing the seed that birthed Cenarius even as the other mothers and Malorne whispered into the seed), wife of Malorne, Tauren Goddess of the Moon, Eye of the Earthmother, the Golden Moon, the Light of Lights, the Light of the Moon, the Light of a Thousand Moons, the Tidemother, the Light beneath the Tides, Sworn Enemy of the White Moon, the God of Death, the Lucid Dream, the Monster in your Nightmares, the Fiend of a Thousand Faces, the Dead Moon, the God with 7 Heads, the Beast of a Thousand Maws and Mother of the Blue Moon!
At the hour of Mu’sha’s 3rd death she will usher in the Void Lords’ coming…