Dumb Thoughts: The weight of the world

Something that has been percolating at the back of my head for a while, and it got brought up quite succinctly when Anduin and Genn were discussing the dead brought back from Lordaeron after attempting to capture Sylvanas and the Forsakens’ capital.

“We’ll be calling up the farmers next.”

Every war that Azeroth has faced, from the 1st and 2nd Orc Wars, the Chaos Wars, the Outland Counter-Offensive, the Northrend Offensive, the Cataclysm War, the Iron Horde Invasion, the Third Legion Invasion, the War of Thorns and then the Shadowlands Campaign, the death-tolls have been staggering. Whole generations wiped out. Massive death-tolls to the point even the people necessary to produce enough food for the nations to survive as something other than hunter-gatherers had to be called up and forced to fight.

How many people went home? Compared to how many shipped out? How many people lied about their age to stand up and fight for their people and country, and how many officials turned their faces away because the dire necessity of the situation meant every available hand was needed on the battlefield?

Re-reading the First Thunder series from DC (Seriously, get it, it is one of the better depictions of super heroes and how they struggle with the cost of their heroism) and I came across this infamous scene.

Imgur

Imgur

Imgur

Imgur

Imgur

Imgur

Imgur

Imgur

Imgur

Imgur

What does the veteran do when they come across someone of their own faction who has screwed up badly, goes to chew them out and sees … a youth. Still round-faced and soft, not yet old enough, surely not old enough to be enlisted, too young for this burden and nowhere near prepared for the cost of it all.

Do they rage at the new recruit for putting themselves in harm’s way, or do they take them under their wing? Do they take chunks out of the officials and generals who allowed this to take place, and force the youth back into civilian life, or do they insist on taking all such ‘new recruits’ into their service, to ensure they do get the chance to grow up, and go home.

Do you have a character who lied about their age to sign up to the fight, only to find it wasn’t all honor and glory, parades and medals like the bards and war-chanters spoke of, but holding your friend as their ruptured guts boiled out of the ragged hole in their belly, or feeling that first, sickening vibration up your arm as spear met flesh, that awful resistance for a half-second before the weight and momentum carried it through, and you stared up into the eyes of your enemy, wide and wild with shock and fear and pain and saw your bloodied reflection in them?

Or are you a veteran who has seen it all before and has become jaded to the loss, the suffering, the muffled crying and the retching at the sight of a corpse from these far-too-green new recruits, and tries not to get too close, knowing all too well that most won’t make it through the next month at best. Or do you instead force yourself into their midst, becoming the Team Dad/Mom/Parent, desperate to keep them alive, whole and sane, trying desperately to hammer in your hard-won and blood-soaked knowledge of how to survive on the battlefield to these naive and bright-eyed foolish children who have no idea what they’ve signed up for?

3 Likes

Man, Joshua Middleton is a god.

1 Like

This post reminds me of this movie, this scene:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aNVNBWLVu_4

1 Like

I have so many thoughts on this topic but I have to go to work, gonna rain check on this and get back to you all later.

1 Like

At this point in the timeline, with so many years of war, I’m not so sure that the propaganda is so focused on “glory”. So many wars have been the “either we win or we all die”, going back to… the Scourge invasions in WotLK, I guess. I feel like recruitment would be more in the vein of “protect your loved ones - Fight the enemy with us, over there, so you won’t have to fight the enemy alone and on your doorstep.”

Cata’s war was less immediate for EK Alliance, I suppose, but the world updates put the Horde war machine so deep into night elf territories that it felt life-or-death to me - In fact, that’s why I made this RP character: a youth who ran away from her druid apprenticeship and lied about her age to join the Sentinels in Ashenvale, because her mother had just been killed there and she couldn’t understand why the Cenarion Circle was ignoring the existential threat the Horde posed.

…Of course, this character was meant to be biased, wrong on many counts, and too stubborn to easily see the other side of things… but then Blizz doubled down on the “make the Horde do evil stuff” storylines and the natural evolution of this character veered into emotionally unstable “I told you so” territory that I didn’t like to get immersed in, so I’ve never really gotten back into RP with her.

Back to the point:

I feel like so many characters in this setting have experienced that already even without seeking out the war - for so many, this is the reason they join the military, rather than it being a surprise after joining.

Part of that is WoW, by necessity, being and adventurer-friendly setting where danger can strike the good NPC civilians anywhere. Even in the starting zones, nestled deep inside one’s own home territory, civilians are in danger of violence and need the heroes’ help. So to me, at least, it feels like war would surprise the world’s wide-eyed green recruits with the scale of suffering (if they aren’t Scourge survivors, or Legion survivors, etc, etc) rather than the regularity of suffering.

That’s one more reason I want to see more groups like the ol’ Westfall Brigade in WotLK - those very farmers who volunteered to fight in the current war, who can give insight into what the salt-of-the-earth members of each faction think of the current conflict. I like those stories, and they help keep the current expac conflict grounded in the overall setting.

1 Like