They would, they are basically the same race as Dwarves minus the curse of flesh.
Darkcore the Elder
It is good to know the people of this land still pay homage to the olden races. I bid you well, , and offer you this token...
They would, they are basically the same race as Dwarves minus the curse of flesh.
According to Shadow Lands. No, Titan constructs don’t go to robot heaven unless corrupted, no I don’t know why.
Earthen do have the curse of flesh but it didn’t hit them too hard. It just allowed them to have free will.
I didn’t see any earthen in the shadowlands.
That should answer your question
Yes, when they die they awaken as spirits in the veil.
Mind you, there’s probably a unique afterlife for them — Given they’re somewhat beings of order, rather than flesh – But have spirits nonetheless …
From a point of view, you could even argue they have elemental spirits – Given they’re beings of stone & whatnot.
I once speculated the grand conspiracy that the elemental spirits aren’t grand fans of the titans, due to them seizing elemental spirits – wiping their memories, reconditioning them and making them into the titanforged beings we know:
Not the ginger ones
I think it was elaborated on that they have free will now. But no souls
Wait wait wait really?!
Well hold up, they were just robots before? I thought the only thing the curse of flesh did was…give you flesh.
Wouldnt this mean Humans and Gnomes also did not have any souls when they were Mecha-gnomes and Vrykul?
Don’t know about that but yup, the curse of flesh is what made the earthen start to question their keepers more.
It means they’re not all the same or destined for the same place.
For instance, you got mortal souls, titan souls, elemental spirits and the beings of light & void — All which have their own place(s)
Whether Shadowlands retconned it or not — Despite what the Kyrian had said in that god-forsaken disgusting-for-lore expansion, the light DID have its own afterlife — as we saw through the Uuna questline There appear a void afterlife too; which is considered to be ‘comforting’ surprisingly also.
It’s as Velen said: “The Light wishes suffering on none, my child. But it does not reign unopposed in our realm.”
I’ve never seen an Earthen soul in the maw or in Zerith Mortis.
The destination of various beings and their souls — depending on the individual or the circumstances of their death, their afterlife can vary - Such is probably the case with the Earthen too.
I could not find anything about it granting them free will, but I did find it:
“had unintended consequences; it gave rise to mortal qualities of necessity, such as courage, resolve, and heroism.”
Which is something else I did not know about. Do you know where I could read about the Curse of Flesh causing the Titan created races to question there makers?
Earthen too.
they arent real theyre rocks they dont have souls
My ‘Release spirit’ button would beg to differ.
… Also my shaman would beg to differ – Many elementals of earth have elemental spirits
Hence another former statement of mine:
Elemental Spirits?
From a point of view, you could even argue they have elemental spirits – Given they’re beings of stone & whatnot.
I once speculated the grand conspiracy that the elemental spirits aren’t grand fans of the titans, due to them seizing elemental spirits – wiping their memories, reconditioning them and making them into the titanforged beings we know:
Elemental Spirits forged into Titanforged?
warcraft.wiki (dot) gg/wiki/Observational_Report:_Earthen
WoW head and other have a whole article about how the curse of flesh affected the Earthen and what it did, what it didn’t do, how it is still affecting them via the story, which we see in the coreway.
glorified paperweights don’t have souls
warcraft.wiki (dot) gg/wiki/Observational_Report:_Earthen
Huh, interesting, so these Earthen we met WERE infected by a variant of the curse. That I did not know, but I mean, wouldnt they still of had free will before the curse?
Oh and I did not see, earlier in the thread someone posted this, a soul of a Earthern:
It is good to know the people of this land still pay homage to the olden races. I bid you well, , and offer you this token...
do Tauren have soles?
Well, do they wear shoes?
They were more robot like than they are now before the curse. You can see how it affected them because they are slowly stop talking like a computer and using more…“human” sounding sentences.
Less “initiating conversation” and more “let’s talk”.
Thats true, i suppose they could have not had free will but still had souls.
Not in the traditional sense no. To them their collected data / memories are their soul.
So they would either be in the memory bank, or frozen inert in their bodies. Not really part of the cycle, at least not like us.