I just noticed this myself. Frankly it’s not acceptable to remove an anti-harassment feature like this suddenly and without notice. If I wasn’t running an addon that auto-enabled it and I didn’t finally pay attention to the errors it was throwing I’d have no idea this was happening.
The only thing I can assume is this is a cost-cutting measure and a rather pathetic penny-pinching one at that. It’s one more tiny little thing they can rip out that databases won’t have to handle. The goal I’m sure being to hard-merge all achievements account-wide along as part of the warband feature. I wouldn’t be surprised to see character-specific achievement tracking removed in future as part of this as if they’re not going to allow displaying the separate versions to others I see no reason why they’d keep tracking them internally.
Some of us have good reasons for wanting to prevent people from tracking all of our alts. Some of us have dealt with persistent stalkers, harassers, etc.
Some of us just don’t like having the most disturbed people on the internet making repeated random toons to scream abuse (always careful to avoid breaking tos by not using bad words) in whispers at all of our alts as we log onto them, not giving us any peace over:
a forum post they disliked, over the fact we refused to trade them a piece of loot they felt entitled to in a group, over the fact we bought out an auction they accidentally underlisted and refused to pay them the difference or return the item, over the fact they were kicked from a group we were in and want to take it out on us, over the fact we wiped and they want to rub it in someone’s face that they think that person is bad and should be driven from the game.
These are all real examples I’ve experienced of people who’ve made a character in the past on a server to whisper me stuff, not all of them would have gone to the trouble of tracking my alts and harassing me on all of them but some might.
As someone who plays on RP realms I might add another, people can take In-Character RP actions incredibly seriously. Ask anyone from an RP realm, there’s always drama, guilds falling out with other guilds, people who because of one RP interaction (in-character, good faith) decide to blacklist a person and spread rumors about them and demand their circle blacklist them as well. It’s crazy but until now at least we had a way of somewhat containing these types of people and their campaigns of harassment, exclusion, drama, etc.
This is a feature that’s been in-game for over a decade and was added shortly after alt tracking websites started to become a thing in 2012 (patch 5.0.4).
Blizzard, give us this option back immediately. At the very least they could allow us to falsify and fuzz the earned display dates via the website and in-game to make alt-tracking harder (e.g. show all the achievements but with an option set the earned dates are fuzzed per character within 6 months to a random date).
Edit: There is a fix. In the account section of bnet on the website under privacy an option called “Share Game Data” if set to disabled accomplishes the same purpose as this but in a more comprehensive way across your account. Thanks for not documenting anything Blizzard.