On these forums, I do not have the option to select my Classic Era versions of my characters that are clones. When TBC came out, I originally transferred my characters (this one and another) to TBC. I then cloned them as well to Classic Era.
I have logged out and in on my account. The listing hasn’t changed. It’s been like this since the split.
This character I’m posting this with is the TBC version. I cannot select the cloned Classic Era version that is in an entirely different guild.
I Realized this in trying to sync a character on warcraftlogs. Before that I just figured the character was bugged since it kept showing the ‘wrong’ guild name for me and I could not select any other level 60 Orc Warlocks on my account named Lovepony.