Derek died fighting for the Alliance. That is pretty formal. Sylvanas uses fighting and dying for the Alliance as a common cause among many. But she acknowledges they did fight and die for the Alliance.
Horde and Forsaken Characters in the game should look at any Menethil or Proudmoore with suspicion. And even casual lore observers should recognize the incongruity.
The Alliance of Lordaeron. Not the Alliance of Stormwind.
If having fought for the Alliance of Lordaeron makes someone a Blue character then most of the Forsaken and Sin’Dorei are Alliance characters.
The Pallid Lady’s champion thing. Maybe that was a PTR detail and not data mining, but either way it wasnt present in game.
Also far as I can tell only Calia refers to herself as the Pallid Lady which is, pretty cringe. It’s not a great name to begin with and now apparently it’s her own nickname she’s trying to get going.
Stop trying to make fetch happen, Calia.
Sylvanas did more fighting for the Alliance than Calia ever has. What Horde roots? She was Ms.Orc & Troll Slayer in the 2nd War and only went to the Horde as a last resort.
I’m just saying Calia never fought alongside any human nation, never had any ill will toward any races of the Horde, and seems to genuinely care about the Forsaken.
But she had a not unpleasant conversation with two humans a few times so. She’s a traitor, I guess.
See what Belmont has to say, he says Calia is only a temporarly shield. To protect the Forsaken from the worst of the Alliance. There’s a lot of click dialogue. Delaryn explains why she won’t go back to the NE’s.
Calia is a patsy. The Forsaken will never be Alliance.