We’re in a loop! In the new teaser trailer Blizzard just released for the 11.2 patch “Ghosts of K’aresh,” Alleria, Locus-Walker, and Xal’atath have an exchange almost word for word from a cutscene from Shadowlands. In both scenes, one character says “We can’t trust her!” First it was Jaina, now it’s Alleria. Another character responds “I’m not asking you to trust her, I’m asking you to trust me!” First it was Uther, now it’s Locus-Walker.
As I recall this was also something Locus Walker said right before he said trust him… “Trust no one Alleria, not even ME.” followed a few minutes later by: “I’m not asking you to trust her, I’m asking you to trust me!”
We seem to always team up with the bad guys now.
Bellular made a video where he called this a unique twist. Its not unique because it happens all the time now. There is redemption or justification for most of the major villians now and we work with them in some way.
It’s a pretty common trope.
“I’m not asking you to trust [insert name here], I’m asking you to trust me” is often used in any situation where there’s a trust issue between reluctant and tenuous allies. Shadowlands was hardly the first time it’s been used in story telling.
Not only that, but motifs are also a very common story telling tool. This isn’t the first, or only, motif that Blizzard has employed in their writing. Patterns exist, sometimes accidentally and sometimes on purpose, in any story that has been going for as long as WoW has.
When is Alleria going to do something other than chasing after people she never catches? First she ran through the Dark Portal to pursue the Horde, then she run pursue Gallywix, then she run pursue after Sylvanas, and then she pursue Xalatha… She is taking the windRUNNER of the family very seriously.
In the span of 3 expansions, Sylvanas had already challenged the Keepers, started a world war, committed genocide, breaking the sky of Northrend and had the arch of redemption.
In the cinematic where Uther and the others are talking about Sylvanas with regard to trust, at no point does Jaina or Uther ask the others to trust her/him with regard to Sylvanas. Thrall raises the point of trust in that cinematic. Saying, “How can we possibly trust her?”
No one argues that she should be trusted. No one argues to trust them instead of her.