With the release of season 7 a few days ago I made my opinion of a tier list for all the episodes. This is why I shouldn’t drink coffee after midnight. Season 3 imo is the pinnacle of Black Mirror, and season 5 was flat out awful and if you haven’t seen those episodes you’re not missing much. Feel free to tell me why I’m wrong.
(I didn’t include Bandersnatch, the create your own adventure movie)
S: Playtest (s3e2), White Bear (s2e2), Plaything (s7e4)*, Hated in the Nation (s3e6), Black Museum (s4e6)
A: The National Anthem (s1e1), Shut Up and Dance (s3e3), Men Against Fire (s3e5), White Christmas (s2e4**), USS: Callister Into Infinity (s7e6), Fifteen Million Merits (s1e2)
B: USS Callister (s4e1), Bete Noire (s7e2), Beyond the Sea (s6e3), Hotel Reverie (s7e3), Nosedive (s3e1), Demon 79 (s6e5)
C: Arkangel (s4e2), Common People (s7e1), Smithereens (s5e2), Hang the DJ (s4e4), The Entire History of You (s1e3), Be Right Back (s2e1), Eulogy (s7e5), Joan is Awful (s6e1)
D: San Junipero (s3e4)***, Loch Henry (s6e2), Crocodile (s4e3), Mazey Day (s6e4), Metalhead (s4e5)
F: Striking Vipers (s5e1), The Waldo Moment (s2e3), Rachel, Jack and Ashley Too (s5e3)
*Shoutout Roko’s Basilisk
**I know this was technically a standalone feature but Netflix puts it in season 2
***Before everyone grabs their pitchforks: San Junipero is objectively a very well made episode and I know most people probably have it in S-B tier, however I enjoy the more thriller/horror episodes rather than the love story ones