No he didn’t
Your looking at Crit Rate…and I agree he is -9% short, but his buff dropped.
Your skipping over Miss Rate…and he is +8% above his stats.
He had a 12.83 total miss rate. He is hit capped, but Parry is 14% and Dodge is 6.5%
His buff fell off and he rolled great on total Miss…this was a great parse for him. Even if he hadn’t loss the buff it still would have been an average parse for his skill.
Fasc…for the love of God!..he was tanking in Cat gear…with FR added in slots that gelled with his Cat gear.
He was 1800 HPs short of where Shift would have been and was wearing no AC in trinkets, rings, no enhanced AC cloak, no enhanced AC shoulders, and obviously using an MCP.
He was in FR CAT gear!
If you look at his gear most slots won’t see gains in TPS values even with further drops.
He is using FR where Taut Dragonhide would be, but you have to put it somewhere. A DFT would allow him to use a Quick Strike and Wristguard of Stability as swaps…but thats really about it.
If you compare Shift to him:
Shift +2% Haste.
Shift +3% Crit w/Kings
Shift +250 AP or so
Shift = -7% Hit
He gave up alot of tanking profile for threat. But his stats for threat are excellent…just because they are blues doesn’t change that.
Just look at Malfurion’s…its a better BP than Bloodthirst…but for TPS its actually a loss. We consider it a gain because it allows for other TPS gains…but he didn’t sacrifice much except EH.