Dextructive:
You’re right, it’s not broken. It worked flawlessly in BfA. My argument is that too much Astral Power, and the Eclipse mechanic, are the problem. I had more than enough power and fun and skill flexibility from pooling two Starsurges that hit REALLY hard. Moonfire, Sunfire, Wrath and Starfire all need to hit hard in their own right. The spec just needs to be slower and have more agency (like it did before the latest iteration of Eclipse). If Starsurge gave Empowerments that could be spent on EITHER Wrath or Starfire with modified bonuses to DoT Procs or something new from spending these resources, Boomy would be fixed; engaging, skillful and fun
All of this is given to players with the current Hero talents and them changing Eclipses from rotating to allowing you to choose which eclipse you want and when you want it