Perhaps i misread what you had wrote. It looked like you were trying to defend their behavour.
Seem to be a number of people who think the OP should have relinquished lead.
Why?
Who owns raid lead in an AV BG? Somebody in the premade? Why? what gives them any more right of ownership than any other pug that gets it?
Maybe you donāt want it and chose to relinquish it when asked. But what if you want to keep it? How is it not your clear right? If the premade people think they own lead, how come the system didnāt automatically give it to them?
Are you guys arguing that just because somebody demands to be given the lead, the other guy is supposed to give it up?
If you arenāt leading or doing anything like marking, give it to someone who wants to do it. or at the very least give out assist. its 2 button presses.
well, per op they were winning at the time the demand was made, so it sounds like OP was doing a fine job as raid lead.
Thats how you approach it. Evidently thatās not how the OP feels about it. Why is your way correct and his is not?
Thatās the great thing about WoW, we are all equal here or should be. No pay to win. No way to force otherās to play your style. There is not one correct way for anything here.
Again, pre-made is an assumption. The OP never said the group was a pre-made.
Come on ā Do you really think that it was all about being desperate to win and not more about a powerplay and showing the dude who was boss?
If a 39/40 premade communicating over discord was going to be even more than slightly inconvenienced for 7 minutes on their zerg to Drek by not having tanks marked then they are a bunch of noobs.
They made him do what they said because they are elitist bullies - pure and simple.
So it was just some stray pug dude who felt entitled to raid lead then? Why should the OP give him the time of day let alone the lead?
The team winning is not an indicator the OP doing a good job as lead, yet another total assumption.
Itās not about being desperate, and I highly doubt it was a powerplay. Marking tanks and reorganizing groups helps you win. Not doing so is just hindering your ability to win even if its only slightly.
If it was a 39/40 he probably wouldnāt have had lead at the start. and to those groups r11-13 time in game matters with how AV is played right now.
Iāve decayād down to 4 dont @ me.
I donāt think anyone was wronged until the threat went out.
Every AV Iāve been it has 40 people shouting instructions. Why should the person randomly assigned be expected to give it to anyone?
It was his choice to keep it. Nothing more.
It was the other players choice to bully him. I hope they get a good long ban.
So lobby Blizzard to auto-assign lead to the highest rank player. But . . . thatās not how itās done. The OP had the same right to the lead as anyone else, so he chose to keep it.
You DONāT think turning the minor inconvenience of not having tanks marked for one 7-minute AV into a āGIVE ME LEAD OR YOU WILL REGRET IT!ā followed by a clear violation of TOS to grief a player, followed by a smug tell when he came back online was a powerplay?
so you assume he isnt doing a good job as leader and must pass lead to a total stranger who rudely demanded it based onā¦ what information exactly?
The whisper at the end for sure. Leading up to it tho. It makes me think OP did more than he said went down. Only blizzard will know with the chat logs though.
Arenāt premades great? LOL
We canāt assume that ā weāre discussing the OPās version of it, and I think weāve all seen comparable bastardry over the past month or so. Itās not too much of a stretch of the imagination.
yea, this sounds pretty in line with what iāve come to expect from some premades. see: lilā baby bruce and his forum ragefits.
To be clear, I am not condoning the behavior of either side here.
But there are always two sides to an argument and right now we only have half the facts.
For all we know the person that requested Lead could have a completely different recollection of the events and they might have even warranted the actions.
Point is we just donāt know and to make sweeping judgement of a persons actions without the decency to get their side of events is shameful.
Yes, I said shameful, everyone who is jumping on the āThe OP was wrongedā bandwagon should be ashamed for having jumped to conclusion without even trying to see that they did not have all the facts.