I agree, defense cap, hit rating, mp5, expertise, the old talents and making hybrids - not just doing cookie cutter… The talents were nice because you felt invested, you spent 10 points here to get this extra benefit… Or saving up gold and only being able to buy 1m of your new spells. I remember farming some lvl 46 elites for hours just because I didn’t wanna quest anymore and they dropped 1-2 BOE epics that I sold… The professions were amazing and had quality to them, i look at professions now and im just like bleh… Yeah I can use jeeves/mailbox/nitros but the only thing im using from this expansion is the wormhole, admittedly when I have more time I might use the mine to guard caps but still it just lacks the flavor…
Or more importantly, I think one of the best memories for me was actually having to get your hands dirty in older raids, I remember in WOTLK there wasn’t catch up mechanics until they added those 3 late heroics so prior to that, you had to jump in naxx 25 to get raid gear so you could PROGRESS. As soon as this next raid in retail comes out all the old content will basically be moot, the same will be said for the subsequent raid tiers…
I thought it was one of the coolest things about classic/bc/most of wotlk, newer content didn’t invalidate older content (unless you are justin some top tier guild and are getting carried as a fresh max level)… It gave you PURPOSE to farm older content. Take for instance the ‘tears of bitter anguish’ from WOTLK. Thing was amazing for enhance and one of the highest simming trinkets at the time, only beaten out (IIRC) by the couple of trinkets in ICC. The tears trinket was a world drop from those valkyrs, I farmed for it for a couple days and got it!!! Meaning that as old as the content was, it still had a purpose and didn’t get 100% invalidated by the new pvp trinket, the new zone’s timeless trinkets or the very next raid tier…
Furthering that thought, I’m also under the impression that blade of the thunder fury was still VERY useful for holding aggro in BC which to me, is amazing gameplay. It makes your character FEEL like its BEEEN places, like the PAST MATTERED. Like my time invested in the character had meaning…
Personally, what I think they’ve done wrong the last 4ish expansions started with the prune… Like I remember getting excited about new expansions and seeing “ohhh priests are getting power infusion” …" OOO were getting x/y, I wonder how that will help"… Now instead of that sense of ‘progression’ its just a borrowed power and its taken away, that or we get it back 1 expansion later in the form of a legendary. Point is, the base form of the character isn’t being built upon anymore, its being destroyed and rebuilt every expansion practically… You enjoy playing disc healer in MoP and like smiting? Well too bad… You enjoy gladiator stance on your warrior from WoD? Too bad… You enjoy demon form on your warlock or enjoy the glyph giving you demon wings?? LOL TOO BAD… You enjoyed combat rogue??? TOO BAD… What’s that? You REALLY enjoyed long arm of the law gameplay for ret?? LOL tooo badd heres this gimmicky righteous charger… You enjoyed having 2 tank specs as a DK? frost/blood?? LOL NOPE, ALSO WERE TAKING YOUR UNHOLY/BLOOD AURA TOO GG