A tribute to Dedicated Insanity bug? with logs, sons of hodir tabard?

WoW Classic WoW Classic Bug Report
1

Hello, after a thorough review of our logs, and thorough audit of all our gear before raid. We seem to have encountered a bug with A Tribute to Dedicated Insanity. The best thing i can guess is that perhaps the new modern tabard from Hodir worn by Dkdaniel bugged. I would like to get confirmation of what actually messed up our achievement run and if theres a way we can prevent this in the future.

We did this with a different set of characters last week, so we know the rules.
classic.warcraftlogs /reports/3m2pZhAqag76NXVz

log we successfully did it with: classic.warcraftlogs /reports/hWX8TRbHv1ZqwgPF#fight=17

2 Likes
2

this is relevant to my interests

3

would also like to know.

4

me too :frowning:

the GM ticket said to post here.

5

Hopefully they look into this for you

6

Without getting into too much detail (hopefully),

We looked up the logs for this, and the issue wasn’t a bug with the item. One of the players in the raid got caught with a 252 item on when a boss encounter began.

It was their boots.

4 Likes
7

Wait a second, why havent you all given clear rules with changes? I had another thread opened asking for clarifying questions about weapons, crafted and/or badge gear. (Even pvp gear cuz i have seen logs with people getting it with 245 relentless cloak… so are 252 cloaks from ulduar okay to use??)

If you have replied or have something we can use as a reference that would be GREATLY appreciated

8

The rules are clear. Anything works except any ulduar 25 hm gear, togc25 gear, and onyxia gear of any kind.

1 Like
9

Looks like someone forgot to change their Nitro Boosts keybind.

If anyone wants guidelines, these were collected by the community some time ago:

What‘s confirmed working/allowed for Dedicated Insanity:

* ToGC 245 tier 
* Uld 10 hm weapons (successful logs with fusion blade/amice equipped)
* Herald gear (239 set)
* ToGC 10 gear
* 245 Relentless pvp off pieces

What’s not working/allowed/unconfirmed:

* Crafted 245
* ToGC 10 cloak
* Uld 25 hm or valanyr 
* ToGC 25
* Onyxia gear
* Badge gear like the rings/relics/etc
  • You cannot have weapon swap or gear set macros with illegitimate weapons or you fail the achievement (bank them)
  • You cannot zone in with the wrong gear or you fail thus requiring a reset
10

There’s logs confirming togc10 cloak, badge 245s, and crafted 245s.

11

But 245 Boes shouldnt work… because they are items from TOC25….
It really shouldnt be a big deal for them to clarify, there is an old post from 2009 that did, and gear that was once 239 and allowed is 252 and not. (In some instances)

So idk why it can just be clarified instead of people playing games across discords and other outside sources. (They added clarifying language to Herald….h

1 Like
12

Idk man the old wowhead posts are pretty accurate. Logs for dedicated insanity confirming badge/crafted 245 https:/ /de.classic.warcraftlogs. com/reports/PmHG9nrktdF7QfN2/#boss=-3&difficulty=0

13

Kaivax is the man for even confirming this.

2 Likes
14

Confirmation is a screenshot/video that backs up the log. The log doesn’t confirm they got the achievement on its own.

1 Like
15

You can look up the popular weakaura author who also confirmed it. This is a player from Razorfen on an achievement discord server claiming his group got it. Not to mention old wowhead posts confirm it. Take their word or not.

I’m also the one who wrote the original post you’re alluding to.

16

Warcraft logs would only catch it if they are in combat, so this confirms that for the achievement it begins tracking as soon as you talk to the guy to begin the encounter, NOT when you enter combat.

3 Likes
17

If you check the raw log.txt for the raid night, you can likely find the offending item yourself. WarcraftLogs ignores COMBATANT_INFO events for several of the fights, but they are still output by the game’s combat log. These are the events containing each player’s equipped items at the time of the ENCOUNTER_START event.

1 Like
18

Thank you very much for taking time to review and answer this Kaivax. I truly appreciate you guys putting eyes on this and answering so quickly.

to some of the others in the thread, ya im very very knowledgeable about the rules, we’ve done the achievement in our other groups, and i did it back in the day, so i can answer any questions.

…Now if you’ll excuse me, i must go beat some raiders with their own boots.

2 Likes