I wanted to bring this achievement to the attention of the devs and suggest some fixes. This achievement is really obnoxious and un-fun as it stands.
The achievement is not something you can bring your casual or undergeared friends to unless they really know the fights. You get 1 chance per week, and 1 player can ruin it for the entire raid. I take part in various achievement runs for old raids and events, and it’s always a great mix of skill levels. There’s complete casuals who only do LFR to M raiders from top 50 guilds.
I was in a run that attempted this earlier in the week and 1 player who didn’t really know the proper positioning on Mugzee got clapped by the tank frontal and ruined it for everyone. It was miserable. The player who died felt miserable and it was a poor experience all around. Achievements like this should be fun and not function like “the Immortal” title of old Naxx glory days.
I have some suggestions to make this better; either would work:
-
Make the coins(or color splash) respawn after One Arm Bandit dies, and the only requirement being to kill Mugzee with the dye buff
-
Make this a personal achievement akin to the Sprocketmonger or Torq/Flarendo ones
This would go a long way to making this achievement less annoying and toxic. Thanks!