I see my last post here was 24 days ago. I was at a little over 800 IO. I’m now at 930, and still experiencing an awful, awful time getting into PUGS for +10 and higher keys.
I’m staying in my wheelhouse, and only applying for keys one level higher than the highest ones I’ve timed, but the rejections are just crazy. I’ve been in one +11 key, almost two months ago, that I got in to pushing a +7 with a good group back when I had about 600 IO score and 355ish ilvl.
I have +10 Freehold, Atal’Dazar, and Waycrest timed. I’ve never been accepted to +11s for any of these. Despite 900+ IO, 376 ilvl, the previous key completed in time, and my noting in the text box that I have flasks and food.
I think it’s the DPS. When I was gearing up, and through about… +6 or +7 keys, I was almost always #1 on the DPS meter. I don’t know if the other classes catch up with the increased ilvl you encounter above that, or if it’s only really exceptional players I’m grouping with for higher keys, or both, or something else, but it’s been second or third on the DPS meters for me since about +8s, despite my not actually doing anything differently, and steadily increasing my ilvl. (376 now!)
I see some folks are griping with IO. I’ve only been back to WoW since September, after 11 years off, so I haven’t spent as much time with it as some of you have, but I quite like it. It’s a direct reflection of your experience completing Mythic+ dungeons, and an invaluable tool to use when trying to form a competent group for higher keys. I’ve only been around three months, but I’ve seen more than my fair share of high ilvl folks who don’t seem to know how to do the dungeons.
The problem with it isn’t it, it’s the people. Specifically, folks setting unreasonably high requirements for groups. Yeah yeah, I get it. It’s their group. They can do what they want. Doesn’t mean that’s not part of the problem. For someone in my boat (with a few +10s, the rest in +9, and a 900 ish score), I need +10s to up my score. Having a 1k score requirement for your +10 is a problem for me.
I’ve tried to use a realistic metric of 20 less than the key is worth, x10. (600 for +8s, 700 for +9s, 800 for +10s, etc.) I think it’s far more important to consider whether the person has completed the previous level of the dungeon you’re doing in time.
But seriously. I want that bird. Nuts to everyone who keeps rejecting me from +10 Freehold. I’ve done +10 Freehold, on time, several times. I have 376 ilvl and a 930 IO score. You have 600. Or less. Why does your thing say you’re checking IO when you’re very clearly not? I hate you, and I hope your group fails. Oi!
Sometimes I wonder if they’re just rejecting me because I’m a monk. I’ve seen too many groups needing one DPS reject me, then change their title to “need range” or “need rogue.”
Sigh. Just my two cents.