After watching the WCR panel and gameplay from the convention, these are my current thoughts about WarCraft III: Reforged.
I believe the core gameplay should stay the same for now, unless you decide to add some other expansion in the future. The main place where you should look at refining is the campaign. Making it similar to all the places and lore we’ve seen from WoW and other media is key. Quel’Thalas can finally look like Quel’Thalas, same as Silvermoon and the Sunwell. Sylvanas could have a bigger impact, her death a bigger impact with an awesome cinematic with the new models. This is stuff I want to see.
Has for the stuff you’ve showcased so far with The Culling, this is my feedback:
Awesome changes to the map, making it look like the WoW version, so that the lore adds up. Though the original seemed much bigger and varied, even with a zoo in the city, so perhaps you should look at making it bigger and more varied, but keeping the WoW feel.
The assets are gorgeous, but the terrain felt more flat than the original, maybe from a lack of sharpness or varied textures.
Some units and lack the readability from a far that the original units have like the Footman, maybe a bigger and more distinct shield would help. The Dreadlord with his wings looked too big, while Arthas seemed a tad small. The same could be applied to icons, from abilities, to unit portraits and items. They need to be almost at a glance recognisable, so that a player instantly knows what he’s looking at and doesn’t need to read a tooltip.
Remastered music would be great, if it is possible, since all other areas of the audio department seems to be being remastered.
Add the Demo campaign to the original campaign since it is lore relevant and explains the origins of the Darkspear Trolls and what happened to the Horde and Thrall during his voyage to Kalimdor.
The cinematics lacked the gravitas of the original one. Arthas addressed his troops on a hill, it was also raining. In WCR he only seems to talk to Uther and then Jaina. I understand this could have been a quick temporary cinematic for the showcase and is not final, but it is important to keep the spirit, mood, to an extent cinematography and even lighting from the originals, or the impact of characters decisions will be dull.
Again, I’m sure it was just for the showcase, but having the map with Arthas’ travel route was cool and it made the world feel bigger, hopefully you’ll bring that back as well for all the campaigns but more accurate to the current lore.
Buildings and other doodads seem too cartoony than the actual playable units. There seems to be a slight disconnect there, so perhaps scaling down on the realism of the units might be a good option.
That is it, a bit of a long one but I love this game and franchise for many years and I hope this remaster is the best it can be.