Personally I love the dedication to revamp this game.
However, I feel the animations look too much like cartoons, as if they are something you see on a mobile game. Which is me also hoping this isn’t a push to test it out on PCs then go to the mobile market.
I would like to say Blizzard would never make Warcraft a mobile game. But when they made Diablo a mobile game my opinion changed
I also feel like its too cartoonish… Warcraft 1 2 3 was bloody and brutal, it should stay so…
I agree. It looks a bit cartoonish, a game for little kids. Warriors should look more fierce.
I don’t understand is this an mock post? Half the people complain on these forums that the animations are not cartoony…
Because a lot of the posters here are perhaps kids? I am a veteran gamer from war3 times and I feel this game like SCR is made for those old times players of us. I know some may still like the old graphics but why would you pay money for a remaster that looks more or less the old way? (not to say what more cartoony than before, overwatch?)
So as we grow, the graphics should reflect this game for more grown up people. Of course, melee visibility of units clearly distinguishing still being leading.
So I agree with the OP.
You may be agreeing with the op but you may not realize the definition of a cartoony style in art.
^ What matters to me is less fancy colors, as for the warriors being fierce or not I will not nitpick. For example I wouldn’t want to see overwatch type and war3’s old style but something that looks more like contemporary strategy while still finding balance between that and visibility for melee. Textures are a lot that matters whether something looks more realistic or cartoony, the model meshes are not something I care about and I know they would be a lot more work to remake.
An example of terrain that already looks better to me, yes this is a map from sc2 with war3 assets:
i.imgur. com/04c8rtM.jpg
Are we even playing the same game?