When they say no one is perfect, the tempest is just there to clearly illustrate that and serve as a reminder…
I had whined about mutas forever. Heck, it’s why I’ve only gone 3 stargate builds for the past 3+ years, cause there’s no other way to play macro games without losing to mutas. It’s something that should just be an obvious fact by now.
Initially, the tempest was designed to deal with the muta problem. When David Kim introduced the tempest, in the video, he’s like we know Toss has a big problem with dealing with mass mutas, as there is no option at the moment. The tempest did splash damage to air. It was supposed to be our solution.
So, why did it change? Dustin Browder straight up said… they had to change it because they couldn’t figure out how to balance it. Basically said, I want to make a pizza, but since I have no idea how to do that… I’ll settle with dumpster diving.
Ever since then, it’s just been random justification after random justification and just trying to make up roles for the tempest, that it just ends up failing at, too. The next reason for the tempest existing changed to “we hate colossi wars and this unit will end that.” Reality? The worst unit you could possibly make vs colossi were tempests. No hyperbole. Anytime I saw someone making tempests, or even after the fact, I just a-moved them and won 100% of games.
Then it became like oh… it’s the broodlord killer! The tempest was so slow moving… and so costly and so bad against anything… that you feared so much that anyone would make a broodlord, because it put you in a lose/lose position. Even if you somehow killed the broodlords… you were stuck with tempests doing nothing. Just wasted supply. And, more than that… your army now had to move at the speed of the tempests… to protect the most useless unit ever. It was just comical and sad. Absolutely horrible.
Then, it became “it deals with liberators.” Look at aligulac and see the leading race stats to start LotV. Terran was the leading race every single period, for years straight, while Toss was “trying to use the tempest properly.”
It simply has no purpose or at least fails to adequately achieve w/e it’s supposed to exist for. It needs to be buffed or removed. Normally, I’d say… just leave pointless units… but there’s lower league players that are going to be losing games simply cause they made tempests… Feels wrong…