Why I Dislike the entire Symmetra Rework already

It really depends on where you put it.

Again depends on where you put the shield. Imagine putting the barrier at the point at Ilios ruins. Your team’s Widow has free reign while the other team’s sniper has to move past the shield to do anything useful and that new position might not have the best sight lines.

Even Hanamura second point, Attacking Soldier loves to perch at the high ground. Drop a barrier at the point and he is forced to come down from his comfy position.

The point is that that barrier has the potential to control the battlefield. You are forcing the other team to react or move out of their comfortable position into some place that has inferior sight lines or puts themselves at more risk if the barrier placement is clever.

For the mobile point, you are not using the barrier to protect a payload. You are only using it when a team fight breaks out to give your team an advantage. As for the high ground around the point thing, the answers I gave above should suffice.

Then don’t do that.

I would argue that the best time to put down the barrier is when the enemy is pushing the point. That way they are committed and a sudden barrier cutting off 1 or 2 of their ranged DPS for 2 to 3 seconds could mean all the difference in addition to all the stuff I’ve already mentioned above.

Sounds like it’s going to be a rather fast ability. I’m more excited for it already.