We know it wasn’t Brig (this time). But who could it be? My top suspects:
- Ball: Has a voiceline about speed eating and no sense of property rights.
- Sombra: Probably didn’t eat, but may have stolen.
- Junkrat: He’s a shifty character. Pie stealing isn’t outside his criminal inclinations.
- Ana: She has a dark side…
5 Likes
Hanzo likes sweet things, could have been him.
Kiriko could have blinked in just as Mercy was leaving…
It’s Bap duh!
Remember the time he took D.Va’s cola? He might of taken the pie along with it.
Or it could be Mercy too since she’s longing to know Torb’s wife apple pie recipe

3 Likes
Cassidy. We’ve seen him be shady with pie already. Bro had an entire slice at a cafe and paid 25 cents. Maybe a dollar. He’s already known for pie theft.
4 Likes
This is the one, no doubt
Well even if she did, you’d have no way of knowing 
1 Like
The shipping drama continues.
I DID IT AND IT WAS DELICIOUS
HAHAHAHAHAHA
WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO ABOUT IT HAHAHAHHA

1 Like
Torb. Didnt see him coming. The pie was was his wifes recipe and torb didnt want mercy breaking down the pie to find out the secret recipe.
2 Likes
I blame Roadhog. He looks like someone who wouldn’t be able to resist gobbling it up. I imagine some other food went missing too!
1 Like
it was me it had poison in it
Places pie neatly underneath large wooden box that looks suspiciously like a trap…
“Here Mercy, Mercy, Mercy…” 
could be widowmaker since no one would suspect her. always saying she has no use for cookies or sweets but actually is a closet sweets eater
Torb was jealous that no one would try his meatballs. So he ate the rest of the food, so that nobody had any choice but to have his meatballs
2 Likes
I just baked a cherry pie from scratch last night. It was delicious.
1 Like
Cass: he has a canonical love of pie
1 Like