Glad somebody has said this. You’re absolutely right and I’ll tell you for why.
They’re completely generic. That is, take Push for instance. Those maps are completely symmetric. Contrast that with Kings Row, one of the best OW1 maps by far. The music is better, the atmosphere, the story behind it (The Tracer / Widow fight). It’s no accident they chose Kings Row assets for the PvE mini games. Then Kings Row is designed around its character’s gameplay, with plenty of places for snipers/ranged, a decent choke with some inventive workarounds for progression. Narrow pathways and cuts. Contrast that with Colosseo, eugh. Generic albeit okay music. The main hall familiar to anyone who’s played Rialto. Then what’s essentially a bland tunnel, followed by the same underpasses you get in the other Push maps. A dizzying LAZY symmetry so you can hardly tell whether its your own spawn or the other you’re pushing toward. And next to ZERO story behind it, just some vague suggestion “a future hero” might be from there. Tracer is from London. Kings Row screams London.
There’s no comparison. Little to passion went into OW2, it was salvaged from a trainwreck. They cannibalized OW1 and remade it with OW2 assets (punchy sound effects, they were good, but generic cartoon character icons, the old ones were frankly much better, if not as uniform).
Just look at who they trotted out for Blizzcon, the OW section had about as much charisma as a wet-paper-bag, blithering on about vague nonsense that nobody cares about. Reminiscent of the lead up to the OW2 launch where they lied through their teeth (I’m looking at you Keller) and skanked a bunch of folks who thought they were buying the OW2 box set only to find it was a bunch of unrelated junk.
I played OW1 classic mode (community mod) in the custom games section, it was fantastic. Everything that OW2 isn’t.
They took out Hanamura, one of the most poignant and beautiful maps in the game only to replace it with this upcoming map which we all know will have cherry blossoms and no character. That was completely unnecessary. They also did it with a bunch of others which were crucial to the storyline.
Instead of ripping those out they could have adapted and upgraded them easily. Adding on extra zones or at the very least reworking the weather.
People play OW as much for the charm and quirky appeal of the characters and original maps, as the game disappears further and further into the mindless bland aesthetic these middle of the road imaginations drag us into, with no idea or stake in the story, Blizzard will have finally become just another Disney.
RIP