So far from what I’ve played, it feels like a push overall. I’m not willing to say it’s outright better, but the sky is definitely not falling yet in my eyes.
The cleave is missed in the situations where they’re massed up (this may have ripple effects like ult charge time), and the winston matchup in particular will need time to really judge, but in the normal cases where the other tank and I are just boxing, I don’t feel worse off. A big thing that people don’t talk about with fighting barriers is that it’s never in a vacuum. I’ve never had to deal every single point of damage to a Rein shield or something, even with the least helpful of teammates.
Against Rein, you were always meant to out-footsie him with the range of pummel and staff, and the damage typically got healed up. While you can’t just checkmate him in the traditional sense any more, he will have to back off if you bust the shield, which is now basically always under threat if you were pressuring at all beforehand.
Sigma’s barrier is extremely precious and he’ll call it back after like 2 hits now. The barrier dancing is harder to beat, but he just can’t keep it up for that long.
Brig takes longer to 100-0, but you were typically not getting her to begin with unless she engaged with dash like an idiot. The main thing here is that 2(?) hits disables dash if she kept it full.
Cage match was always a weird case of how to approach, so more time will be needed to figure out what the play is when outside or inside.
I haven’t fought Zarya yet since the patch hit, but that’s the one I’m most interested in. Cleave didn’t do anything there, so the bonus damage is preferred if you’re intent on breaking it.
The Ram barrier is temporary and stationary, so you ran through it if you were winning or waited it out if you were losing. Using it to dance for a sec to wait for your Nemesis cooldown may be a thing in the mirror now, though.
Big loser against the Sym ult. Having to actually acknowledge it is unequivocally a nerf, but that’s kind of a “Oh I have to learn to play normally now” nerf.