Happy Expansion Day!

[Ghaghzull-1888]

everything is broken yet again…

[LadyDeadpool-11517]

Kil’jaeden is pretty fun n crazy

Starship deck is enjoyable too

[Hazama-1175]

Whoever that green butthead is, he probably feels pretty slow atm.

[SparkyElf-2852]

@WorriedCheez-1780

I know there’s some type of election today, but we’ve got more important things going on!

Ha-ha, good one!

What election, by the way? Isn’t the [REDACTED]rigged[/REDACTED] one in Moldavia over already? Haven’t heard of any interesting or significant others lately.

Anyway, you’ve got a point here. Although I’ve had no intention of playing Standard yet, maybe we’ll see what their intentions regarding Twist are and whether they’ll keep it up, so who knows, perhaps I’ll see some of you in the tavern indeed.

[Dallaen-1426]

LOL i played 7 games and 5 were Quasar Rogue with 2 being elemental Fire Mage(IE: New Lamplighter). Lost to them all trying to actually play for the board. How stupid of me to think playing these silly starship cards would be part of the meta in any way. Not one of my games went beyond turn 6.

[Qwark-11381]

I played a few hours of this expansion launch today and tried many new cards and deck ideas. This is without a doubt the worst balanced expansion launch since United In Stormwind.

The game feels like a complete mess right now with absolutely zero player agency. Constant turn 4-6 OTK’s now with Quasar Rogue, Elemental Mage playing brain dead turns over and over, 90% of the new cards being complete garbage compared to all the old cards, Starships being completely unplayable bad in every class besides Death Knight, even if you do build a Starship it immediately gets stolen by Reska, MCT or Yogg-- or any other number of ways to just instantly nullify it. I could go on.

Worst expansion launch in 4 years without a doubt.

[t0rnado-1269]

First expansion in at least a year that generally offered a real shakeup, though to achieve that we got insane power levels to supplant old meta decks. I hope the new Shadowverse game is good. I’ll still have MtG, in the end.

[SparkyElf-2852]

@t0rnado-1269

to achieve that we got insane power levels to supplant old meta decks

As always.

Already have written why recently, lemme just quote it here, too:

@SparkyElf-2852

There’s another big issue related to the model of Standard HS in general, and that’s the reason why so-called power creep (and thus also insanity creep?) is seemingly inevitable. I think that ‘Old Guardian’ fellow has discussed it in one of his videos, but I don’t feel like looking for it now, so I’ll just explain it in my own words.

Let’s assume you have a powerful card set (‘set’ in a maths-like sense, in HS terms that’d actually be three ‘card sets’ or ‘expansions’, but no matter) for a Standard year X. Obviously, it means that year X+1 cannot be less powerful than that, so if you’re trying to tone down the ‘power creep’ and ‘insanity’, you could only do it in the year X+2, when the card set of year X rotates out. However, that, in turn, would require the cards from year X+1 to be toned down as well — and is it really feasible and possible? If set X+1 is much weaker than set X, then there’s no incentive for players to buy it, and that’s a failure for the company (by the way, the same pertains to set X+2 in relation to X+1, obviously). Thus, the alternatives are as follows: either you essentially ‘skip’ a whole year in terms of sales and releasing useful cards for a healthier meta in the next year earliest, or just keep ramping up the ‘madness’ and the sales. The choice is quite obvious, but even if they did choose the former option for a healthier game state in the long term, I’m not even sure many players would appreciate it (here’s a classic… Classic… example… Hmm, what a pun it turned out to be), besides, there’s also this ‘excitement’ trend, as aptly noted above.

As a result, I’d expect all the ‘madness’, ‘power creep’ etc in HS to increase steadily (see my post above about ‘progress’) and not the other way around.

Of course, there are possible alternatives to that model in general, such as overall rebalancing from time to time to compensate for the accumulated power creep, for example, but they haven’t done it in HS, and there’s no sign that they intend to do so.