Artist Colifero and Magtheridon Unreleased

I used overplanner on turn 7 and chose Magtheridon as my second discover choice. Then on turn 8 i played Colifero but Magtheridon was not the card he was the card after. So he moved from second choice from overplanner to third.

If any card has been shuffled in your deck, then your whole deck has been reshuffled
It would only be coincidental that Magtheridon was moved one position further

But doesnt overplanner put three cards on top of your deck with first pick being the next card to be drawn second is 2nd etc…

The thing is, Colifero doesn’t say “draw a card”, it says “draw a minion”, which means it got a random minion from your deck, without altering its order. Magtheridon never left its position.

Yes, but after you’ve set the order of card sin your deck, if any card is shuffled in your deck, your whol edeck order is randomized.
However this is not the correct explanation to your case, Mux is right about this.
“Drawi a card” will always draw the first card on top of your deck.
“Draw a minion/spell/beast…”, any card that targets a specific draw, will pull a random one from your deck, not necessarily the one on top

ahh i see thank you guys for the explanation