Obvious S goes to Schnoz, being a one of a kind pet model and the fact his animation for collecting items is sniffing it off the ground is peak.
A goes to the black knight itself, armor looks phenomenal from the cloak(ruined if you have garbage wings on), the rigged armor and the one red eye on the helm… this along with dragons layer is amazing.
B is skull night, iconic helmet, great looking weapon and awesome armor. Definitely a great looking cosmetic
C is the rogue sets… Griffith set while yes accurate has never really looked good and the weapon is just goofy on the class especially the melee animations. The other rogue set looks better but tbh only reason to get it is for the prosthetic arm… so a $25 prosthetic arm cosmetic
D Tier are the mounts… they look mid asf and the game has mountains of better mounts you can get.