Tempering Scroll Isn't The Answer

Yes, it’s great that it’s being added, and it should be added, but there needs to be adjustments to how tempering affixes are weighted, or just how tempering works in general.

I can already foresee players tempering an item 6 times, bricking it, using a scroll, and then tempering it 6 times and getting the same exact affix all 12 times and still bricking it.

I know a lot of work was done on this system, and it’s a core piece of the gameplay now. But it needs work. Not just a scroll. (“Oh, this’ll fix it guys, just throw a scroll at them, no problem.”)

And no, I don’t want the correct affixes handed to me, but I shouldn’t get 6 of the same affix in a row.

Currently there’s 2 pain points to tempering. 1) Getting the exact same wrong affix 6 times in a row. 2) Getting the lowest possible value when you do finally get the right affix.

I would prefer each temper opportunity always gives us a different affix, but with a lower chance of getting a high roll. Then we spend Tempering Scrolls to keep trying to get the affix values higher. Each time I use a scroll, it gives me back my tempering opportunities, but I have to find the correct affix again, but I also have a higher chance of the values being higher. Then I feel like I’m working towards something, rather than leaving it all up to RNG. And this will create a more streamlined experience, rather than one player really enjoying the game because they always get the right temper rolls on the first try, versus someone who rarely gets the right affixes and are continuously using Tempering Scrolls to find the right affixes.

I’m not saying remove the RNG of it, but kind of ease the RNG of it. You still can brick an item, because even if you have 4 options on a tempering recipe, you could roll 3 of the 4 options, just not the same one back to back, and still not get what you’re looking for. But at least I won’t see the same exact affix 6 times in a row.

1 Like

Didn’t read it all but as long as it’s very rare yes it is

You should read my post lol. Has nothing to do with how rare the scroll drops. I actually don’t mind the scroll. And I’m glad they’re adding it. My gripe is adding the scroll but not fixing the inherent problem with tempering.

I think you should be able to select exactly which affix you want but at a high cost of gold and mats. Make it so high that you have to plan which items you are going to temper.

1 Like

Wake me up if they implement your idea, or any idea regarding tempering that’s on the forums.

2 Likes

Yea that’s my point they added the scroll because this dev teams math isn’t the greatest per the release and every season up to now lol. This imo was the easiest and best way for THIS team to fix the problem.

I’ve had plenty of ideas that I’ve posted on here make it to the live game. Poison smoke grenade was one of my ideas, finally made the live game in S5. I also suggested that they tweak the tempering recipes so we don’t have useless affixes on recipes when tempering for a specific build… which they did, in S5. The trick is to give a very vague idea, and let them develop it into their own. They won’t directly use someone’s idea because it could potentially lead to some unwanted legal action, whether they would win or lose the battle in court, they won’t touch it. And I’ve noticed that they wait to see if a bunch of people give similar feedback and then they kind of mold all that feedback into their own idea.

They can easily take this idea and mold it into their own. In fact, they don’t have to use anything similar to this, but just make tempering better in their own way. Which, they’re game devs, so they can figure that out much easier than you or I could.

It also helps to contact the devs directly on Twitter if you know their @'s

Hi Shil Pwift here for Tlex Fape and you have a terrible problem with tempering. So what do we do!? We add some Tlex Fape bandaid it right up!

I genuinely believe you believe this. So again I say wake me up if they implement your ideas. Rooting for you sport, good luck.

Adding a retemper scroll is a workable idea. If they add scrolls and get all recipes down to three or four choices that fit a theme, that should get us to a decent point.

Dev math 1:1 == 4:100

Apparently the blacksmith doesnt know how to temper or is just a sedistic f***. The system is lame as hell. I think you should pick what you want and let the effectiveness be rng. Who the hell has time for this s***.