Armor Stat Not Matching

Armor Issue. My armor defensive stat is different from my profile armor stat. One says 8763 and the other says 9288. Why are they different? Feels like I’m not at cap any longer since the update. Definitely taking more damage.

Did more testing and when I remove all armor, both stats are still different. Even when out of town.

More testing. Removed all armor. Stats are different. Removed golem and skellys and now stats are the same. Added armor back, stats are the same. Added Golem back and now stats are different. So my question is which defensive armor stat is it reading since one is lower than the other?