Both are pretty junk. You want Str + Vit + All Res + Life% > Armor >= LpFS.
The ancient (with practically any legendary roll) will be significantly better, since you can put all res and it already has str and vit. The minor damage loss would be nowhere near the massive loss of 130 all res or 650 vit.
Yeah, I would have salvaged both of those. The obvious thing to roll off is the skill bonus damage as its completely useless. As for what for, probably Vit.
wait…you can get an ancient or primal Lamentation???
I was sure that wasn’t possible since the piece of junk I’m wearing on S19 toon is the absolute best that has dropped for me so far. Even blew through a couple challenge rifts worth of bounty mats reforging…
I noticed your Barbarian doesn’t have any physical% buff on any item. I wonder how much DPS that actually adds? I only have it on one item myself. Is it critical for GR pushing? I just don’t know.
Yeah, I stopped reforging when I got an ancient with STR / CHC / CHD / CDR / Socket as I felt that was good enough. Non-seasonal, I’ve got around 1200 of each bounty material, but almost no forgotten souls. Seasonal, I’ve got around 300 of each bounty material, but over 20K forgotten souls. Maybe when the season roll-over happens I might splurge the amalgamated materials on trying for a unicorn.