Staff of Herding, so I did it

I started to kill izual, check leorics fireplace, and look for mushroom, and liquid rainbow ever bounty i joined either during or after. I got them

Then all I had to do for hours straight is a speed run to Cavern of Frost to kill Chiltara over and over. If the Icefall caves has a bounty or you see the Icefall caves immediately close the game and restart. You can do this many many times an hour.

But do all the other parts during or right after bounties. It wont feel so grindish. If I remember correctly, you can do all this on normal mode too. Difficulty doesn’t increase rate of quest drops.

Trying your method now. No reason not to! Just finished Act 1. Probably the last time I’ll be playing D3 since D4 is going to come out – so it’s fitting I do the campaign which I haven’t done in like a decade.

Just wish I could skip all these dialogue sequences.

Took me 30 minutes… 3 CoF 2/3 had the Boss.

This is being exaggerated horribly.

I only made 53 games. 29 were caverns of frost, so the remaining games were icefall caves. Almost 50/50. Chiltara almost spawned in every caverns of frost too. Very close.

I’m amazed people still don’t know how RNG works in games in 2023. It’s been about 8 hours for me. Over 300 games. You got very lucky. That is all.

1 Like

I think farming Holiday Gifts for 3 hours a day for nearly 3 months gives me a decent idea of how RNG works. It’s just ironic that after hearing all the horror stories so many players are getting this item completed in one play session.

So I’ve done the campaign to the area where the frost caverns spawn. And Chiltara is in there every single time. That’s nice! However, there’s a blindspot here I wasn’t thinking about. I can’t look to see if there is an ice cavern or glacier bounty for that area, then instantly remake. So I’m hitting a lot of games where the frost caverns don’t spawn. With that problem, I’m not sure this is a faster method.

I got the staff of herding done! (in a few hours, not sure how many, max 3 I’d say, probably 2).
However… I still don’t have any Ramaladni gifts! :open_mouth:

Almost 400 games in, and finally:
https://i.ibb.co/QQKMsgV/Screenshot-1.jpg

over 100 kills of Childara so far and still grinding… Carpel tunnel setting in… still no end in sight…

Oh the item description font is very large, I like it!
Is there an option for that! :open_mouth:

Hmmm it’s standard as far as I know. Maybe cause it’s a cropped screenshot it looks bigger.

1 Like

Haven’t tried yet but I did kill Izual twice and he hasn’t dropped the plan yet. I figure I won’t bother getting the ingredients until I actually need them, or at least have the design.

Fortunately, on console, there are only two hard ones to get - the Gemstone and the Mushroom.

I have more important things to worry about, like getting my dang Haunted Visions. Or a Broken Crown.

I’m actually farming a second one just for fun. Already completed everything and getting 2 primals per drop. :slight_smile:

Got my staff yesterday.

  • Rainbow and mushroom I found totally accidentally when leveling to 70 by running bounties
  • Leoric took 5 attempts
  • The plan took ~25 Izual kills
  • Gemstone took ~60 new games and ~20 Chiltara kills

Seems I got it quite easy.

2 Likes

Compared to many yeah. My grind this time was nowhere near as laborious as previous attempts. I guess I am one of the lucky ones in s28. Of course, now I just started HC and watch that be a real __________________ of a grind to get all the parts to make the Staff of Herding. I’ll have to post that later on for comparison.

Oh I can game a few hours, cant do multiday sessions anymore. Anyway got the stone, one more primal ancient drop and I am done with the altar.

lol same. I got all the other mats except the plans, and farmed a long time to get it.

Don’t mean to belittle your effort, but it’s all about RNG anyway.

It took me a little less than an hour and a half to complete the staff.

Like you I did multiple tasks in each game until the last one.

Raxx’s Staff video for S28 really helped.

1 Like

I spent about an hour for Staff of Herding. It wasn’t hard after all. I remember farming for it back in a days to open cow portal. Chilantra is what took the longest for me, but it was reasonable grind.

2 Likes