I disagreed, and explained why, i.e. such a tiny sample size of results can have wildly varying results compared to a much larger sample size. You can’t reliably extrapolate from 8 data points and it’s asinine to attempt to do so.
You claimed a 1:8 ratio of main stat to vitality on crafted items based on how you feel. I immediately thought that this was unlikely to be true, based on my own experience crafting but I offered to help test this out because I wanted to find out. I did so because I prefer to base my opinions on how things actually work rather than how people think things work.
The results of my 180 crafts was that the ratio of DEX to VIT was almost exactly 1:1, i.e. not even close to your claim of 1:8.
A week ago you were going to craft 250. Now you say you have 442 more to check? Where did the extra 200 weapons come from? Anyway…
From my existing 180 weapons, we already have these results…
DEX = 109 weapons (60.56%)
VIT = 104 weapons (57.78%)
Let’s assume, for the sake of argument, the 450 weapons you crafted obeyed your claimed 1:8 ratio of DEX to VIT. That would mean your results would be…
DEX = 50 weapons (11.11%)
VIT = 400 weapons (88.88%)
That would give us a total sample size of 630 weapons, with the amalgamated numbers of…
DEX = 109+50 = 159 weapons (25.24%)
VIT = 104+400 = 504 weapons (80.00%)
How about, in the incredibly unlikely scenario that not a single weapon you crafted came with main stat. That would give us a total sample size of 630 weapons, with the amalgamated numbers of…
DEX = 109+0 = 109 weapons (17.30%)
VIT = 104+450 = 554 weapons (87.94%)
If your ratio was true, the correct result for a sample size of 630 crafts should be…
DEX = 70 weapons (11.11%)
VIT = 560 weapons (88.88%)
So, regardless of what the results are from your 450 crafts, even if not a single one of weapons had DEX on them, it still doesn’t get you to a 1:8 ratio.
My point of view is based on the fact that it’s mathematically impossible for you to prove your claim, even if 100% of the 450 weapons you’ve crafted don’t have DEX on them. But, by all means, take as long as you like to post results that can’t prove your case any more…