I’m not arguing against punishment. I’m arguing against unnecessary cruel punishment. I agree the boy deserves to go to jail but you keep moving the goal posts.
You actually said in not so many words that the world is doomed because kids that are criminals will always be criminals and never ever change except by experiencing cruelty in turn.
I’ve showed you that kids are kids and can be cruel. Now I could go into all the studies that show the human brain isn’t fully developed until at least age 25. High School ends at age 17 or 18 and so a person can’t be defined until at least age 25. But you argue that because these kids are cruel in adolescence that by the time their brain is fully developed, they’ll continue being cruel.
Anyway, I can only suggest you seek therapy.
Edit:
I mean, you bring up this “terrible horrible school system you teach in” and that all the students are bad and there’s no hope for humanity. Then say, “No what I meant is there is this good girl, but these other kids are bad and because of these bad kids the world is doomed.”
But the existence of this good girl flies in the face of “the whole world is doomed”. If there are good kids and bad kids in school, then the world can’t be doomed.
Edit #2:
Since you like telling stories about how bad kids are.
Try this one for size.
As I told you, I was bullied back in school. In one instance, I was sitting in class and this one kid was talking stuff about me and my mom. Dutifully, I just sat there and ignored it until suddenly this kid decides he’s just going to hall off and deck me in the middle of class.
The teacher saw it. He also saw the other kids in the class grab me and hold me back from defending myself. Everyone eventually sat down but no cops or anything were called. No punishment for me or him for fighting in class or anything. The teacher just ignored it like nothing had happened.
Later in that same year, another student punched that teacher in the jaw. Suddenly, that mattered, and the kid wound up getting arrested for assault.
Earlier in my school years, I was sitting in class one day, and these three boys were messing with me. So, I got up and those three boys got up and I walked around my aisle into there’s. I grabbed the first kid, pushed him into the second and both of them into the third and pushed all three against the wall and screamed, “Leave me the F alone.”
I then let them go, went back to my desk and sat down and cried like a baby, and again, no one said nothing. The teacher just let it happen. No one went to the principal’s office or anything like that.
So, if you’re going to argue that the “world is doomed because bad kids do bad things” then I can argue that bad kids do bad things because bad teachers won’t do anything about it until law enforcement gets involved.
Edit #3:
And another thing. Regarding this incident you keep bringing up, I can almost guarantee that it wasn’t teachers that called the cops about this boy but the parents. I’m also willing to bet that the teachers knew full well what was going on with the video sharing and were willing to look the other way. But when the parents found out all the teachers including yourself suddenly got all insecure in your teaching methods and decided to say, “We just didn’t know…”
Yeah, sure. I bet this girl sat through weeks of torment before she finally told her parents because I can bet the “teachers” didn’t give one whit until they saw that some heat from the public might come their way.
Edit #4: Fix’d some grammatical errors because I was a bit upset when I typed this and realized I wrote several run-on sentences.