Hi everyone. Below some of my ideas/thoughts i would like to share.
[Itemization]
Number of affixes
As we know there is no main character stat (str/def/int) in current version of items. Is it good? Imo it is, also i don’t mind there is only attack/defense ‘indicator’ until there are other affixes like cc, cd, etc… but the number of them in items should be increased deffinetly.
White/blue/yellow items purpose
In D3 these items are trash and mats sources only. To avoid it in D4 and give them some meaning here is my idea:
white - require for crafting (see number 3)
blue - mats source
rare - using on character until upgrade
Crafting
As mentioned it would require white item + some mats etc. But what would make crafted item competitive to Legendary item? ONLY crafted item would have 1 affix more than every item. Example based on D3 item: Legendary item has legendary power and 4 primary stats; crafted item has no legendary power but has 5 primary stats.
Ancient set/legendaries
Ancient items are a good idea in D3 where legendaries drop rate is extremely high but in D4 with smaller drop rate (i really hope for it) it can cause that ‘basic’ legendaries will loose their uniqueness and become trash. There are two options to avoid it:
remove Ancients items at all,
make Ancients items ethereal (from D2, item that cannot be repair), it is stronger version of basic one but after some time it brakes and become unusable
Drop rate of legendaries
It should be something between Ancient and Primal chance to drop in D3. When Legendary drops it should make a smile on our face and require time. NO for D3 legendary rain drop.
Runewords
I have played a lot in D2 and i love rw from it. However i like an idea of rw from D4. In D2 we were getting a full ready item, but there were only few where we cared about stats, mainly we cared about some extra other class’ skills. In D4 system a good thing is that we can use it in every type of item, i mean white, blue, rare, set and legendary (D2 only white). I see a lot of possibilities in builds, but hope there will be more combinations 3-4 maybe even 5-6 runes.
[Trading]
Ad you know Blizz sugested 3 types of items:
Tradeable with no restrictions
Tradeable once and account bound after
No tradeable at all
Imo there shouldn’t be point 3. All items we can find should be tradeable. White, blue, rare, runes, gems should belong to group 1. and all craft, set, legendary, mythic items to group 2. Period.
[Weather/enviroment system]
I would like to see some iteraction with it, not only a visual effect. Example: snowy area would cause -X cold resist; desert -X fire resist, rain -X light resist or +X light dmg dealt, something like that.
[Key dungeons]
I like the idea but i am affraid that it is GR2.0. There shouldn’t be uncapped Key levels. It will make we will get another XX difficulties, items will be buffet with every patch/expansion and we’ll be getting more and more numbers… make it simple. Make 3-5 levels of keys only. Keys should work only on highest difficulty and highest dungeon level (40? for now). Basic dungeon lvl40 should cuase an effort on us already and every key level should double (or x 150%) the difficulty. Example: level 1 key doubles basic dungeon; level 2 doubles level 1 and x4 basic dungeon; level 3 doubles level 2 and x8 basic dungeon, etc. It shouldn’t be easy to reach last key level after week or two of playing. Give us a challenge please.
I love the weather system. I would love to see something like torrential downpours/storms come through and have players rush to taverns or inns to take cover for a few minutes. Nice warmly lit places with vendors and calm guitar. Loud rain and wind hitting the structure. They could have mini games at tables like pinfinger and cards where players could bet items or gold. You could restock on potions, gamble, buy things you can only get during these RARE storms etc. After the storm passes everyone who decided to wait the 2-3 minutes gets a 30 min buff or something. It would all be optional but staying out in the storm affects movement/combat etc and you get no buff.
Little things like that could bring players together and add to the mood. I dunno I like brainstorming. I’d like your post but I have to wait 15 hours before liking another post
Blizzard you NEED to make white bases, magic items, and rare items RELEVANT for character equipment. If you have them exist merely for the purpose of being salvaged, the game WILL DIE. Trust me, it’s one of the reasons why Diablo 3 was so trash. Whats the point of blues, whites, and rares even dropping at that point so you can just salvage them, might as well just drop the crafting material instead of the item. It will make players not even bother to check the stats of items and a lot of them will not even be picked up. Which means they’re useless.
You need to have a purpose, for example white items can be used as bases for crafting, just like how D2 used white bases for runewords. White bases need to be distinguishable, better bases, maybe superior ones like diablo 2.
Magic items need to not be literally useless as well. Make magic items great again like in diablo 2 how you could roll GFG magic tiaras, GFG magic chestpieces (4 socket+80life, etc).
Rare items need to be RARE. When I kill a rare monster or pack of elites, they should not 100% give me a rare item, otherwise might as well call it a common. Bosses should drop 1 or 2 rares max, that’s what makes them RARE. Rares should also compete with ‘legendaries’ in stats, because they need to be relevent or else game is just going to die.
Legendaries respectfully need to be legendary, not some crap that I won’t even read over the stats.
Make every skill with basic dmg only. After leveled up we are getting +1 skill point and every skill would have 2-3 ways to upgrade it (each way has 5 lvls max).
Example:
D4 Barb Bash
(Current)
Bash the enemy with your weapon, dealing 42-51. Has 20% chance to stun for 0.5s. Generates 9 Fury.
(After improve)
Basic: Bash the enemy with your weapon, dealing 42-51.
Option 1. Generate 9 Fury (1 lvl)
Option 2. Has 20% chance to stun for 0.5s. (1 lvl)
Level up: basic dmg goes up and we chose between 2 choices: 20% chance to stun for 0.5s OR generate more Fury per hit. With every next point spent numbers go up.
I spent my +1 point for option 2:
Basic: Bash the enemy with your weapon, dealing 52-61.
Option 1. Generate 9 Fury (1 lvl)
Option 2. Has 25% chance to stun for 0.8s. (2 lvl)
And up to 5 lvl, or balance 1/4, 2/3, 3/2… what we need.
If we’ll have limited amount of points we’ll have to chose what option we want to level to max lvl 5 and what we can sacrifice or we don’t need for our build.
I’m not a fan of trash items, even if they have a use. Collecting all the white, blue, and yellow items in D3 for salvage is not a fun game mechanic. Personally I want to see waaay less items on the ground, I find they take away from the visuals on screen and are a chore gameplay wise. Less time picking garbage up, more time killing things is a win.
At the very least use Van Helsing’s options regarding item filters. Allow us to hide each type of item from sight and also allow auto pickup of each type of item. Van Helsing uses a follower to do this and it works great.
We won’t need any filter if all items will have some meaning. In D3 “normal” Legendaries are trash also.
I haven’t played VH so i don’t know this mechanic woth follower but seems it is a good idea. Ofc if there will be any follower in D4 and we’ll be able to have him in every game mode (as in single as in team).
All items can be used as source of mats. This is to give the player a choice between mats and trade: idealy only the best items would be traded.
white items: i agree
blue: should give less affixes than the higher tiers but with higher values.
rare: same amount of affixes than legendary but without the legendary affix. This would create a choice between more normal affixes or a legendary one.
The only item i could put in group 3 could be the skill books. And could add some very rare runes to the group 2.
I think the problem isn’t for them to be uncapped, the problem is that they keep giving us more power to reach higher. We should be able to get higher bcs we level and make better builds, but in the end that should never be too much higher, it should be really hard.
What you propose here is nothing different than D3. In some cases, you want to wear them, even @ endgame, else they don’t matter.
There should be no account binding at all. We shouldn’t ruin game experience for everyone, only because 5% do RMT.
Also, I am okay with endless dungeon as long as character power remains the same. They can have some better chance for loot, but not to the point they make everything else obsolete. In the end, everyone will just hit the wall, where you cannot go any further. The only reason greater rifts failed is because there was a paragon system, perma CC and RNG (map and mob type) combined with time limit.
If Rare items would be balance good and be usable it wouldn’t be same as in D3. Mainly i suggested mats would come from blue items only to not make all items just mats source. I agree rares should have same amount of affixes (at least).
I was thinking about those skill books as well. If these kind of items are peparing to be in group 3, than i am ok with this system. If runes should belong to group 2 depends how rare and valuable they will be.
I’m affraid that uncapped Dungeons would create XX numbers of difficulties and add only numbers to game in future like in D3. There could be a max level of Dungeon that is veryyyyyyy hard or almost impossible to reach and it would be good imo. It wouldn’t be a wall but some goal, an end game like 99 lvl in D2.