I saw people hating on Diablo Immortal in the general forums but I cannot post there as I do not own Diablo 2 R on MicroSoft Windows.
Anyways,
Yes it’s true Diablo Immortal is an excellent game. The people were posting the metacritic score “proving” that the game is actually considered bad by “most” people. But the reality is that Metacritic is a very small portion of reviews especially compared to the iOS App Store and the Google Play Store.
On the iOS App Store it’s closer to 4.5 out of 5 stars
On the Google Play Store it’s closer to 3.6 stars
Now there are many reviews of people who clearly have not played and are simply upset that it’s a mobile game or that you can pay for a chance at a good item so the reviews are skewed lower but even with those negative “reviews” the game still averages closer to 4 out of 5 stars when you take both the iOS and Google stores and metacritic together.
So yes, Diablo Immortal is worth playing.
No it’s not p2w if you don’t want to pay you do not have to spend any money to enjoy the game you can choose to either spend money or time that’s how the game is designed and I hope diablo 4 is the same way because otherwise it simply encourages people to sell items or accounts on shady websites like what happened for Diablo 2 and Diablo 3 all the time.
The only thing that requires you to pay because you can’t get it otherwise is a resource that upgrades a rank 10 legendary gem but it would take most likely months/years of playing before you’d ever need one of those resources so at that point I think it’s fine for blizzard to ask some money from the player to improve their power considering the game is completely free otherwise (i.e. every thing else in the game is attainable). They could also offer a freebie of this resource once most of the playerbase obtains their first rank 10 legendary gem.
The reality is that people who do not like Diablo Immortal are a very vocal minority and the majority of people in the world are really enjoying Diablo Immortal as it is one of the best games to be released in 2022 and here’s hoping Diablo 4 also comes to mobile and consoles too.
Side note, I love that the p2w store is also tied to RNG, so even the pay2win players are not guaranteed that 5 star legendary gem they desire. It’s essentially like a booster pack which makes it harder for the P2W players to easily “win”.