Maybe it’s just me but I’m against the idea of using someone else’s mats to skill up and then getting paid for it. Professions are an investment and skilling them up should not be what’s profitable. What should be is having skilled them up. I’ve had no problems skilling at a massive loss and still recuperating, at least with alch and tailoring (when I’m actually allowed to and things aren’t turned off). That being said, selling BoEs to vendors bc I could only make 1 star at the time was def a feels bad. And I can see the argument of: If people could set a minimum quality then why would they not only go for that quality? And tbh I don’t really know. As I stated, I would only go for max. But I think the real issue is that what would be crafting order gear/consumables are required for level up, and if there’s no orders then the items are just vendor trash. So to me it comes down to how much we want to push people to use it versus how much would have to change. Pretty much everything is empty right now, but I do believe adding a minimum quality would at least put more order in the system. But that’s also like, not what I think would really help, considering what you stated. If I had it my way I’d be rid of gear quality. Keep reagent quality relevant by making higher quality reagents required for Item Level changing optional reagents like Primal Infusions. Then if someone wants say, an Alchemist stone with a primal infusion, there isn’t 5 additional options of quality on top of that and anyone who can make it for me just… can. Then those who maybe need to skill more can still have the option to craft the same stone for someone who does not have the Infusion, which would require less skill overall and lower quality reagents. But I’m aware that something like that would require a significant change to the system. But right now with now as it stands, hardly anyone is using crafting orders except privately. If they want more using them something somewhere has to change. Minimum quality on public orders would at least be enough to get me to use them. But that’s not ideal and I feel as though we are working around a system with many cogs and many wrenches in those cogs.