And since that didn’t make it to the game, is not canon. Until a chronicles or some other source of information comes out that stats the canon order of events, there is nothing that states the events of Azsuna occurs before Stormheim.
So Greymane was after petty revenge and nothing more.
I see you’ve run out of arguments and are simply bleating “Hey the peace treaty isn’t broken” but have no logical thinking to wonder “Hey wonder if our dumb stance on not telling the Alliance that it was not what they really think”.
You are the one who’s obsessed with your fanfiction. Learn the lore before you accuse others.
" While Alliance adventurers pursue the Aegis, Genn uncovers that the Forsaken means to plague Greywatch like they did Gilneas. Greymane commands his forces to destroy the plague caches and the invading Forsaken apothecary to secure Greywatch and later sends Lorna Crowley to uncover what Sylvanas seeks in Skold-Ashil. As Lorna discovers that Sylvanas means to create more Val’kyr by subjugating Eyir, Genn musters the Alliance fleet in trying to assault Dreadwake’s Landing. The battle at Greymane’s Offensive goes poorly and his offensive is repelled. After hearing news of Lorna’s intelligence, Genn personally goes to the vault in Skold-Ashil to confront Sylvanas."
All the Alliance knew was the Sylvanas was going to Stormheim and they 100% attacked because they wanted to kill her for personal revenge and for no other reason. They learned of her plans well into the zone story and way after the attack.
Again you are engaged in massive head canon. You have no idea if the horde attempted any form of communication and are just “herp derp horde are dumb and never said anything, so it is their fault”. You are also again ignoring that the Alliance head of intelligence was replaced by a dread lord and giving Alliance fake information. So again you are doing your darndest to play the victim by making it horde’s fault alliance was given false information by the legion and broke the treaty.
You really do love to dodge stuff.
I’m saying it IS the Horde’s fault for thinking there’s any sort of peace treaty when they twiddle their thumbs sitting thinking they are some spoilt brats wanting to abandon the Alliance and expecting them to lay a red carpet.
It’s your head canon that the Horde were wise and good bois to contact the Alliance. Oh wait that never happened and there’s also proof that AFTER the end of the expac we had a little communication between Anduin and Baine (?).
I have proof it happened after the expac and after your claims of this nonsense peace treaty which you assume simply based on “Hey we may have caused a misunderstanding but we demand it stays”.
You have no proof about your sorry little treaty even being valid enough after your faction was bothered about saving it’s own skin and didn’t bother offering a explanation beyond a random Horn training practice.
I dunno. Probably the reason why some orcs call a spikey poop filled hole in the ground home.
Yeah, I’m looking at you, horde WOD garrison…
Verdant trees don’t burn, but Blizzard doesn’t understand that.
The very rules of the universe must bend and warp to make Sylvanas seem like a decent Villain.
No what you are saying was that it was cancelled. What I am saying is that we do not know that and if it was it was done due to the alliance.
Right now you are trolling. YOU are the one who keeps claiming there was no communication and calling the horde stupid for not communicating when again you have proof.
That is completely irrelevant to the argument you are making.
Again your 100% head canon. The horde did not “Cause a misunderstanding”. The Alliance spy chief which lead both factions into a trap and then fed Alliance false information about the horde betraying them cause a misunderstanding. You then continue with your head canon that the horde never said anything after that. I say “we don’t know” you say “horde is dumb and didn’t say anything”. Want to guess which one of these is head canon?
and you have no proof that it wasn’t, but are making up reasons why the alliance broke it by blaming the horde. So if it wasn’t then the Alliance broke it out of being fed fake intel by a dreadlord and if it was then the Alliance broke it our of Genn’s desire for personal revenge. Your every post is so filled with bias as to be completely laughable.
Can you disprove my “head canon” by proving that the Horde contacted the Alliance before the expac ended before Stormheim?
Sadly you cannot. Your entire argument is based on this flimsy assumption that the Horde upheld this peace treaty.
So yes. I’m telling you there’s no proof that this peace treaty was valid after Broken Shore and you seem incapable of backing up your facts of “Hey that’s not right. The peace treaty existed!”
Show me proof then. You can’t can you?
The tauren orc and goblin shaman along with the warlocks of the nightborne and fire mages of the blood elve ensured that it kept burning. They really enjoy sticking it to the night elves.
Because “How dare you not share your forest with us who have no right to the land” in Cataclysm. How mean.
why would you live in a flammable house? everything burns given enough fire.
Lol you want me to now disprove your made up head canon?
So what is more likely? That the horde never sent any form of communication to the alliance or that the horde did? We don’t know either way, but try and use a little logic.
No my entire argument is that we went into BfA with it and if it was broken it was by the Alliance either via their actions at Stormheim or because the leader of SI:7 Mathis Shaw was replaced by a dreadlord.
And I am telling you that there is no proof that it wasn’t and if it wasn’t it was on the Alliance.
Troll away while ignoring the multiple times I have pointed out the only information we actually know.
What are you two arguing about? Who broke the peace treaty?
There is some indication (as the developers said they originally planned the zones before level scaling) that the first zone in Legion was supposed to be Aszuna. And on the Alliance side, the player character finds a ship wrecked on the shore named the “Queen’s Reprisal” and upon inspecting it comes across the captain’s footlocker with the captain’s log. Upon delivering the captain’s log to Lieutenant Surtees in Dalaran, the response is:
The officer looks down at what you’re offering him and his eyes light up.
Do you know what you have here? You might have just delivered some of the most significant intel of the campaign.
I will see to it personally that this gets into Lord Greymane’s hands.
Now, this seems to possibly have been planned to lead to the events where Anduin summons you to accompany Greymane and Rogers to Stormheim (if the developers original intent for the story was to begin in Aszuna and conclude in Stormheim). We don’t know for sure since they changed up the leveling process to mean you could jump into any zone, but it is circumstantial evidence that possibly the Alliance knew Sylvanas was up to something in Stormheim ahead of time. That doesn’t mean Greymane should have instantly attacked the Forsaken forces but we also don’t know how much of Sylvanas’ plans were in the captain’s log either.
Well yes. Nobody is arguing that the Alliance didn’t know that Sylvanas was going to Stormheim. That was the entire reason why Genn was there. 100% of the argument is WHY Genn attacked.
I think based on Genn seeking information on what Sylvanas was planning to do in Skold-Ashil well into the zone is fairly strong proof that he did not know at the time of his attack against the Forsaken fleet and he was just doing it for personal revenge.
If it was information of her plan to avoid dying (by taking control of the Val’kyr) then Greymane’s retaliation for Gilneas was likely.
Most certainly so.
Trying to talk about WoW’s writing is always an iffy thing because 90% of it is just so bad. Even in Classic there’s some dumb bits, like the Night Elves and Forsaken being shoehorned into the Alliance and Horde, then it just keeps getting worse and worse with each expansion.
Oh, I know. I’m sure revenge is never far from Greymane’s mind.
But, the way the quest is handled suggests at a minimum they knew Sylvanas’ forces were going to Stormheim all the way to perhaps Greymane knowing more than he let on to Anduin since the Worgen lieutenant took the intelligence straight to Greymane. Knowing Blizzard, they write the stories this way because any ambiguity allows the events to be interpreted in a number of ways to keep Horde and Alliance antagonistic towards each other. 
You’re really the one who is trolling here claiming “You have no proof the treaty was broken” and still claim “HAY we had a peace treaty after we broke it in Ashran”.
The only thing the Horde is entitled to is to say “The Alliance attacked our Warchief when there was a greater threat”.
They have no grounds to say “How dare you break our peace treaty” after they were content enough to stay silent.