Why can I not skin anything on Siren Isle?

[Rabititus-shuhalo (Rabititus)]

@Primerate-sulfuras

I implied gathering nodes should be available.

I agree, an old mining colony and not a rock on the island. I guess they took it all, ripping all the flowers out of the ground on the way out.

[Myzrym-area-52]

@Primerate-sulfuras

Again, I’ve never argued for compulsory engagement -I’ve stated as much explicitly for you.

Instead you are arguing for farming in compulsory content. I’m not saying you argued for mandatory content I’m only saying that you are arguing for bot farms in what is, objectively, mandatory content.

[Primerate-sulfuras]

@Myzrym-area-52

Instead you are arguing for farming in compulsory content.

Yes, that current content zones should have current content reagents like ore and herbs. A bit unorthodox, I know.

@Myzrym-area-52

arguing for bot farms

Incentivizing activity by adding literally anything desirable into WOW is just arguing for bot farms. lol. ok.

[Myzrym-area-52]

@Primerate-sulfuras

Incentivizing activity

Is already accomplished due to the nature of this ring being a requisite in group content for the following weeks of this season.

We don’t actually need you to have a tiny zone to farm in. You can do that across the rest of the world.

[Primerate-sulfuras]

@Myzrym-area-52

We don’t actually need you to have a tiny zone to farm in. You can do that across the rest of the world.

This tiny zone is supposed to be part of the world. I think it could survive resource nodes without falling into chaos.

[Keymah-moon-guard]

Makes sense, there are no herb nor mining nodes either.

[Snowpine-ghostlands]

@Primerate-sulfuras

Myz isn’t being sarcastic. He’s not joking. He’s entirely sincere.

I’m not sure Myz has been sincere for even 5% of his 15k posts, Prime.

If you genuinely think this, you’re pretty much roped in, though.

[Primerate-sulfuras]

@Snowpine-ghostlands

I’m not sure Myz has been sincere for even 5% of his 15k posts, Prime.

If you genuinely think this, you’re pretty much roped in, though

Quote which post signals he’s joking about his primary premise.

[Myzrym-area-52]

@Primerate-sulfuras

I think it could survive resource nodes without falling into chaos.

It has survived no resource nodes without falling into chaos as well.

[Primerate-sulfuras]

@Myzrym-area-52

It has survived no resource nodes without falling into chaos as well

Sure, but I never argued it would fall into chaos without these nodes.

[Snowpine-ghostlands]

@Primerate-sulfuras

which post signals he’s joking

@Myzrym-area-52

We should not only make the Isle mandatory for continuing your season in group content but also make it a bot farm as well!

Then we can compete with bots just to get our compulsory engagement finished! Brilliant!

I’m not sure how the blatant flamboyance didn’t clue you in.

[Myzrym-area-52]

@Snowpine-ghostlands

blatant flamboyance

river dances away from the thread

[Primerate-sulfuras]

@Snowpine-ghostlands

I’m not sure how the blatant flamboyance didn’t clue you in

yes, that was a joke to drive home the central premise that he’s very much arguing sincerely. You can tell I understood this as a sarcastic joke by replying to his underlying point.

You still haven’t quoted the post where he’s joking about his central premise.

[Snowpine-ghostlands]

@Primerate-sulfuras

that was a joke to drive home the central premise that he’s very much arguing sincerely.

Wild, so when I said;

@Snowpine-ghostlands

You played the same game Myz plays but didn’t like it when he did it.

I was spot on.

[Myzrym-area-52]

The central premise, in all honesty, is that this island is meant to put on pause every other activity you were already engaging in, including but not limited to gathering and group content, so we all get to be taken away from the things we actually want to do long enough to complete our compulsory content.

Farmers are not an exception to this. Nor do they deserve to be simply because Prime wants a tiny box to farm in.

[Primerate-sulfuras]

Are you unable to follow a discussion?

@Primerate-sulfuras

Devs were worried players would spend time on the Isle so made sure that wouldn’t happen.

Here I use satire to make a point.

@Myzrym-area-52

Then we can compete with bots just to get our compulsory engagement finished! Brilliant!

Here Myz does as well, which I fully understand and reply to here:

@Primerate-sulfuras

Is the implicit proposal here that new zones never have gathering nodes or skinnable mobs?

Myz, then sincerely makes this point, which I later call dramatic

@Myzrym-area-52

Well don’t argue for bot farms in compulsory content without making them entirely, completely, and in totality optional.

You then say I’m being dramatic as well by calling attention to my joke post.

@Snowpine-ghostlands

Why does this seem to be a trend for you?

Seeing that you’re clearly misunderstanding, I say that Myz (while at one point joking) is now being entirely sincere as you can tell by his many replies defending it.

Again, the point I called dramatic from Myz was 100% not a joke and quoting that he’s joked early on in the thread is irrelevant. I never called his original joke “dramatic” but you called mine dramatic.

[Primerate-sulfuras]

@Myzrym-area-52

The central premise

Was that me asking for resource nodes is akin to me asking for bot farms.

@Myzrym-area-52

Farmers are not an exception to this. Nor do they deserve to be simply because Prime wants a tiny box to farm in.

For the record, I don’t actually have gathering professions.

[Myzrym-area-52]

@Primerate-sulfuras

I say that Myz (while at one point joking) is now being entirely sincere as you can tell by his many replies defending it.

Argue for no catch up islands then. Don’t argue for your farming to be made easier while everyone else is put on hold.

[Snowpine-ghostlands]

@Primerate-sulfuras

Are you unable to follow a discussion?

Are you?

I sincerely suggest you reread where we’re at thus far, and feel free to look in the top right to check if I’ve edited any of the posts.

For good measure, do the same for the last discussion we had, where you couldn’t keep your proverbial feet on the ground similar to here.

My point’s made, I’m not doing the “I can make myself right if I drag this on forever” again, especially when you failed the first time. Not a coward, but droll.

[Primerate-sulfuras]

@Snowpine-ghostlands

I sincerely suggest you reread where we’re at thus far, and feel free to look in the top right to check if I’ve edited any of the posts.

I quoted it all.

@Primerate-sulfuras

Quote which post signals he’s joking about his primary premise.

Oddly when you originally tried responding to this you dishonestly cut off part of my quote: “about his primary premise” because clearly he’s not

Why can I not skin anything on Siren Isle?

I’m not sure how the blatant flamboyance didn’t clue you in.

I once again ask for where Myz’s sincere point (which he continues to defend) is at all a joke. You haven’t provided it.

It’s not a joke. The only joke he’s made so far, that I can tell, is a joke that supports his central premise through sarcasm. He’s free to argue whatever he wants but I’m not going to have some random 3rd party come in and tell me he’s joking when he’s clearly not. The central premise remains no matter how much you want to say otherwise.