Honestly, I do think people are over-reacting a bit.
Yes, it’s by far the worst quest we’ve had in Korthia, but it’s not impossible as some claim. I finished it in 20ish minutes before reset, then another 20 minutes after reset.
They do need to fix the fact other people can scare away a critter you have already enticed.
They need to fix the fact the critter can just randomly run away when you did nothing to prompt it. (I literally had one run away right after I threw the meat, it got bored and left.)
They REALLY need to increase the timer on how long you have to kill the razorwings. It was quite literally impossible as a holy paladin. A resto shaman in general chat was having the same issue.