Does this mean we’ve put to rest any misunderstandings regarding my first post?
I do realize that, which is why I commented on that but also opened discussion. Do you tank with a 2h weapon? What rotation do you typically use? What talents do you typically run?
Also, do you generate more rage? I realize that rage per hit is higher, but is overall rage increased? I think 3 times more for simply a weapon change is questionable. Are you able to support this claim? I suspect a simple experiment would be, using both weapons, time how long it takes you to generate 100 rage. Maybe 3-5 trials of each?
Again, don’t get me wrong, if the healer is having no problem keeping you up, you do you buddy. If they are though, do the considerate thing and put on the equipment that will help you mitigate significant amounts of damage in the appropriate situations. Still having issues? Consider changing your talents.
This is all an if-then sequence of events that requires you to be aware of your role in a group and how you are performing at it. I think I speak for most people when I say I really don’t give a crap how you achieve it, as long as you are being honest with yourself in your ability to perform it.