it would be tabbo for vengeance to have all 3 hero trees while no other spec in the game doesnt have that option, it also sounds like a balancing nightmare for all tanks that isnt veng. veng was luck to have 2 hero trees because it had 2 specs in general so they had to make them work for both specs as normal. a wildstalker bear would be hard to balance, a slayer prot warrior would be hard cause what can it use to proc its hero specific thing. thats yet another thing to add on tank tuning which is already volatile at best
healers and dps will cry fowl and thats a whole new workload for no reason
tank population would increase if they have more options. peopel will still funnel to the best “hero tree” for all content even tho they dont need the best hero tree for meme content.
its like “add tank spec to x class” it wont increase tank population or popularity. because dps players arnt going to play it long term. only tank players are going to play new tank spec, your just spreading the population instead of adding to it. dps will play with their new toy for a week, buckle cause they dont like tanking and then complain to blizzard about how tank spec for x class was a mistake. or they forget about it and continue pushing the narrative that the only way to fix tank population is to add yet another tank spec to another class.
inb4 source
my source is that every tank spec added to the game didnt r eallyadd to much to the tank population, it was a steady increase but its a far cry to the numbers people hoped would happen. tanks will always be scarce due to a whole bunch of issues that dps players dont like to talk about.
is that enough of a why for you?