Thought on Gnome Paldins

I am not saying there is a line that says paladins can never question anything. I am saying that way that paladins are shown to come to be paladins.

They can have doubts and personal conflict, but the oath itself is taken serious.

We literally see this happen with Delas Moonfang. We watch a new paladin come into existence. She does not think her way into it or treat the oath like a theory. She commits, and the Light responds immediately. That scene is Blizzard showing the process directly.

On gnomes, I am not saying every gnome is the same or incapable of faith or emotion. I am saying gnomish culture, as written, pushes questioning, testing, and revising ideas as the norm. Over time, that mindset clashes with a Light-based paladin .

We have already seen Blizzard run into this issue with gnome priests. They let gnomes break the mold, then walked it back. Most gnome priests are framed more like medics or technicians using the Light as a tool, not people driven by devotion.

Gnomes are not written as a devotional culture, which tracks when you remember they descend from mechagnomes built around function. They still retain the legacy of their orgins as literal mindless robots.

1 Like

Or you and your best buds go out, kidnap one of the living space chandeliers yank it up to magic draining crystals and poof! Instant Paladins!

2 Likes

Outside of Demon Hunters and Evokers, there is not a single race that can’t work as any of the classes of Warcraft. If you can’t see why, it’s because of a lack of imagination.

1 Like

In Warcraft canon, gnomes are defined by rationalism, skepticism, and mechanical understanding of the world. That is not flavor text. It is structural to how they are written. Their origin as mechagnomes and their transformation through the Curse of Flesh hard-codes a mindset that prioritizes analysis over surrender. Even when gnomes encounter belief systems, the lore consistently shows them questioning, testing, and ultimately retreating once faith demands acceptance without proof.

Paladins, by contrast, are rooted in absolute conviction. Their power is not exploratory or conditional. It is sustained by unwavering certainty in an external, immutable truth. Doubt may exist as an internal struggle, but the oath itself is never treated as provisional. The moment belief becomes something to audit, optimize, or revise, the relationship to the Light breaks down.

Because of this, a gnome embracing the Light in the paladin tradition creates a direct lore conflict. To make it work, either gnomes must stop behaving like gnomes, or paladins must stop functioning as paladins. Both outcomes require dilution of established canon rather than interpretation of it.

Rare aberrations can exist in a setting as large as Warcraft. However, rare exceptions should not be used to justify opening a class to a race that fundamentally does not meet the narrative conditions required for that class. Exceptions do not redefine norms, and treating them as justification ignores how both gnomes and paladins are consistently written across the lore.

Outside of lore, from a player base perspective, gnomes are already the least played original race. Expanding classes for a race that historically sees minimal player adoption does not meaningfully impact growth or engagement. If the discussion is no longer about lore consistency, then the more honest question is whether gnomes should continue to exist as a playable race at all rather than forcing class combinations that contradict their foundational identity.

No its expansion of canon beyond that very tiny and tight straightjacket you seem to be determined to put it in.

And as someone who’s played a green hair gnome druid in the past and looking forward to doing so again, I vehemently disagree.

If you want to lock yourself in a box, go to it. But it’s YOUR box, not a cosmic mandate.

2 Likes

I must have missed that part. I only remember her being listed in set of companions, but I don’t think I ever got the quest that activated her.

Yeah in the order hall campaing she takes a whole set of oaths infront of the alter.

Gnomes over all do not fit withing the frame of light paladins. You have to water down one or the other to make it work.

Again, you’re just repeating your constant claim that evey gnome has to be cast in the same identical mode.

Paladins are exceptional beings that break the norms of every race that produces them. Adventurers and Champions by their very nature, do so as well.

1 Like

You keep repeating that I am claiming every gnome has to be identical. That is not the argument. Variance within a race does not mean infinite elasticity. In World of Warcraft, races are written with cultural anchors. Gnomes are defined by intellect, engineering, rationalism, and technological innovation. That is their thematic spine.

Yes, there are a few gnomes who have explored faith. Gnome priests exist. But that actually reinforces my point. Those few are rare, not culturally central, and when gnomes pursue spirituality it is often framed through intellectual discipline or even the Void. There is no established Gnomish Church of the Holy Light. No knightly order. No militant Light tradition rooted in Gnomeregan or Mechagon. No historical crusading culture.

Paladins in Warcraft are not just “exceptional adventurers.” They are products of institutional faith. Human paladins come from the Church of the Holy Light. Dwarves share that tradition. Draenei are shaped directly by the Naaru. Blood elves created the Blood Knights tied to the Sunwell. Tauren formed the Sunwalkers. Every paladin race has a structured religious framework that produces them.

Gnomes do not.

So when you say paladins are exceptional beings who break racial norms, you are missing the scale issue. An exception is a narrative anomaly. A playable class implies systemic existence. Once you allow gnome paladins, you are saying there is enough cultural infrastructure to produce them. That changes the race’s established identity.

This is not about every gnome being identical. It is about maintaining thematic coherence. If race and class combinations ignore cultural foundations, race identity becomes cosmetic and paladinhood becomes generic.

So the real question is not whether an individual gnome could believe in the Light. The question is what pillar you are changing. Are you rewriting gnome culture to include organized Light devotion, or are you redefining paladinhood so that institutional faith no longer matters?

In WoW lore as written, paladins require a militant, structured relationship with the Light. Gnomes do not have that structure. A handful of fringe priests does not equal a paladin order.

That is not insisting all gnomes are identical. That is insisting the lore remain internally consistent.

No it doesn’t. Paladins aren’t the norm no matter what race you cite.

They are exceptions to the norm. Just like warlocks and rogues, and mages.

Did you have the same issue with Gnome Warriors? After all, they are literally powered by rage.

The answer is I’m rejecting the narratrive straitjacket you’d put on any race. That kind of thought is the foundation of most real life cultural prejudices.

1 Like

So the question stands, and it is a legitimate design question:

What gives?

Do you soften the Gnome’s secular, rationalist foundation to accommodate faith-based devotion? Or do you dilute the theological weight and cultural gravity of the Paladin order so that it becomes just “plate armor plus spells”?

Saying “Paladins break norms” does not answer the structural issue. Exceptional individuals still emerge from cultures. They react to something. They reject something. They sacrifice something.

If you refuse to identify what is being sacrificed, then you are not defending creative freedom. You are avoiding the mechanics of character construction.

Standards are not prejudice. Standards are what allow deviation to have meaning.

We have Light users making Light-powered mechs. :sparkles: Science :sparkles:

A compelling counterargument is that a culture embracing relativism, reframing priests as specialists rather than divine authorities, and viewing faith as a practical tool might still produce paladins individuals who uphold moral ideals because such values can be cultivated through alternative means. In this view, instead of relying on divine authority, moral heroism and dedication can emerge from humanistic principles, social cohesion, and personal conviction fostered by societal institutions focused on ethics, justice, and community well-being.

Therefore, the absence of absolutism and traditional religious authority does not necessarily prevent the emergence of moral exemplars; rather, it may inspire a new kind of heroism rooted in human effort and shared values, leading to the creation of modern paladins who serve justice and righteousness without traditional divine endorsement.

More liike magitech.

:sparkles: Magic science :sparkles:

Your counterargument only works if you redefine what a paladin is, and that is where your position breaks down.

In World of Warcraft, a paladin is not just a morally good fighter. It is a specific metaphysical and institutional role built on three things: source of power, structure of belief, and authority. If you remove any one of those, you are no longer describing a paladin.

Start with the Light itself. You are treating it like a tool that rewards general morality or social cohesion. That is not how it functions. The Light responds to conviction treated as truth. Paladins do not just hold values. They assert them as binding and objective. That certainty is what empowers them. If you replace that with relativism or purely humanistic ethics, you undermine the very foundation that distinguishes a paladin from any other class that can act morally.

Now look at structure. Paladins are not self-made moral actors. They come from orders like the Knights of the Silver Hand or their cultural equivalents. Those institutions define doctrine, enforce discipline, and grant authority. That authority matters because a paladin acts in the name of a higher moral law, not just personal belief. If your society reframes faith as a tool and avoids absolutism, it has no reason to create or sustain that kind of institution in the first place.

You are also collapsing “moral exemplar” into “paladin,” and those are not the same thing. Warcraft already has space for humanistic or socially driven heroism. Warriors, monks, and even priests can embody those ideals. Paladins are different because their identity is inseparable from oath, sacred duty, and a divine or cosmic mandate. Even cultures that reinterpret the Light still anchor it in something absolute, whether that is An’she or the legacy of Rezan. They do not secularize it. They reframe it while keeping the divine core intact.

This is where your point about relativistic cultures producing paladins falls apart. A society that treats belief as flexible, practical, or purely human-driven can absolutely produce ethical and heroic individuals. But it does not produce oath-bound enforcers of universal moral truth, because that would contradict its own philosophical foundation.

So yes, moral heroism can exist without traditional religious authority. That part is true. But that does not get you to paladins. It gets you a different kind of hero entirely. Once you remove divinity, absolutism, and institutional authority, you are no longer describing a paladin in Warcraft terms. You are describing something else that happens to share a surface-level resemblance.

What defines a Gnaome more than anything else is obsession. A Gnome can’t conceive of the idea of halfway measures. If a Gnome takes up something, they lean into it to a degree that ordinarly leaning looks like lying down.

And quite frankly, Gnomes can get obsessive to the point where rationality gets told to take a hiked, there are plenty of quests that you do for or involving Gnomes that bear this out

So yes, there is absolutely no reason to preclude the existence of those rare few that can get obsessed for the Light to the point that they take up arms for it.

If Night Elves can be Paladins, Gnomes make just as much sense.

1 Like

i’ve said for years that any race could be any class simply because the entire race should not be judged on the balance of the individual wanting to step outside of the norm. Gnomes and dwarves have lived together for a very long time and there’s no reason why a gnome who doesn’t cling to technology couldn’t lean over to his dwarf buddy and say hey tell me more about this light thing. We saw with season of discovery that it’s entirely possible for anything to happen and personally, I think they also have the capacity to be shaman and potentially even druids.

1 Like

Paizo’s iconic Druid for Pathfinder is a gnome.

Eberron’s ArchDruid is an awakened oak tree.

1 Like