- If it’s a good 2H Axe, then that’s a good drop for Shaman (regardless of who is in the group).
- If the Shaman is elemental or resto, I don’t see a problem with them needing on an Int/Spirit neck piece.
- Enhancement Shaman should be rolling on +Agility leather legs before they get mail.
Out of all the things you’ve listed, only Herod’s Shoulders would be kinda eh… and even then, they may actually still be an upgrade for the Shaman.