Imo brew is ok once you get some gear on your character, but harder than basically any other tank to punch above your item level as far as key levels. Raid tanking it handles very well though. I feel like brew is at the bottom/worse end of what they wanted tanks to be in M+. Dying to white damage while surviving tank busters is just…bad imo.
When I’m helping people get their ksm or whatever I will grab my bear 90% of the time right now, which feels good given where bear has been in past expansions. If I have a healer that can at least top me up from time to time I’ll take my warrior, which is still undergeared for a lot of things but can take the hits, after that I’d go vdh, prot pal, bdk. Each of those have their upsides, I just don’t really enjoy the play styles lately. Nothing against them, just what I want to play atm.