I used to like her. In fact, she was one of my favorite characters.
Now, I’ve seen Captain Planet villains with more depth. They took a pained, conflicted, calculating character and made her into a mustache twirling lunatic powered by purple smoke.
2 Likes
there’s a lot of people who would gladly accept her back, me included actually. and nobody cares that you personally don’t like her, that’s now what this thread is about
She is my favorite character in any game ever
I do feel like most people want her dead and gone which sucks
I really hope she doesnt go
Don’t worry you won’t see her go. You’ll be able to see her every week on Tuesday for the weekly mog run.
I wasn’t talking about the players I’m sure plenty of players would but lore wise nobody would forgive her she has done far too much to be redeemed
She’s the new Med’an.
Bends the lore to make sense, gets overpowered via retcons.
Undead sylvanas has always been evil. since her reanimation, she killed soldiers fighting for their home, tested weapons on POWs, tortured her own troops, and has stated that she cared nothing for the forsaken.
I hope it’s left up in the air as to which side got the KO, 'cause both sides deserve it. Alliance for Teldrassil, Horde for being made into monsters and betrayal.
‘As for who got the killing blow? Eh, is that important? The Banshee-witch is dead! Huzzah!’
Right. I’m going to stay over here understanding her rage against a man who killed her and literally destroyed her races’ glory and lifestyle forever.
She’s right to do so, but you are mistaken if you think she gives a crap about her people. There’s a reason once she got what she wanted in WOTLK she committed Suicide. She didn’t care about the forsaken or her fallen sisters. The only reason she didn’t stay dead was because she was afraid of what she saw of the afterlife.
Her entire character since her reanimation has been one that is fueled by selfish motives. This idea that her WOTLK self would hate her current self is lacking because their actions are largely the same.
For instance
In Wc3 she made an agreement with the dread lords, and after she got what she wanted out of it, she betrayed them (justified)
She made an agreement with the forces of lordaeron, and after she got what she wanted, she betrayed them.
She joined the horde, and after she got what she wanted she committed suicide. And then being afraid she came back to betray them.
TLDR: her character has been consistent for the most part
The only thing that would satisfy me, is if we get to rip her head off personally, no Thrall stepping in and kill stealing, Just PC vs Sylvanas, with Sylvanas losing all her BS plot armor, and ended up dead.
Because canonically she has no loyalists anymore. 
Same. She’s been my favorite character since I started, It’s a shame Blizzard can’t hire decent writers and not just because of her.
I rather see her twerk on Anduin, but that’s another story in an alternate timeline, but sure I would like to see her get locked up for her crimes and perhaps get close to her sisters.
I always appreciate my subjects love. Consider this me contacting you. If I need anything I’ll let you know. 
1 Like
Oh god. You’re REALLY not going to like this Expansion. That’s a good thing in this case.
She doesn’t appreciate you, even if she says so. Sorry Tubmlr comments…
Of course everyone hates her.
She’s not Arthas who was mind controlled by Frostmourne.
She’s not Garrosh who was mind controlled by an Old God.
Sylvanas intentionally was a fascist dictator in the Horde and was stated in WoW lore explicitly as joining the Horde but still having quote: “evil” intentions.
Why is it that the “Loud Minority” is an excuse given to defend the actual minority opinion?