nope
unless i’m mistaken, this talent incentivizes dhs to still press the active gcd of throw glaive. by that token, refreshing the chaotic imprint debuff that was already on a target from tg casts is meaningless. the only exception would be a dh minmaxing with off target throw glaives, maximizing their debuff uptime at the cost of whatever single target damage that loses
I literally included that ability in the list that procs from BD/DS now… You dont have to press throw glaive at all now unless you want to tag a rogue or something. Set bonus makes it do it works off BD/DS and it consumes charges from it.
that doesn’t meet my understanding of how soulscar’s damage is calculated. give me a moment to look up whether i trust you to know how dh works on deeper than an ignorantly speculative level
no i do not
Yes you do if you wanna maximize soul scar. Throw glaive has 2 charges, use them then blade dance cause even if you don’t have charges BD still throws a glaive. Now if you don’t throw glaives it’ll use a charge of glaive.
Edit:soul scar carries over left over dot damage if re applied, I’ve gotten it to crit 60k from a dot.
that’s very surprising actually
regardless, what damaging gcds are closest to pushing tg casts out of your rotation?
Regular chaos strike can crit 40k per MH/OF so 80k total if both crit. That’s chaos strike unbuffed, throw glaive unbuffed (no momentum/inertia) can crit 20k (throws 2 glaives per charge) so 40k if both crit, but it applies a dot which then you can blade dance to throw another when out of charges to maintain dps/pressure.
So you can add more soulscar dam by using throw glaive into soulscar? That actually makes the set bonus even more broken then.
Yes it’s like a SP devouring plague where if you keep re applying it, it carries remainig damage onto new one.
ignite and pandemic have been nearly universal passives for years at this point. assuming this wasn’t the case seems very weird
beating the word ‘broken’ black blue and bloody
I mean, that only helps to reinforce my point that BD/DS needs to be toned down.
Or just the throw glaive from tier set?
Bust most DHs don’t use throw glaive anymore because they are used to tier set atm.
I mean, whatever tones down damage from hitting that 1 button needs to be looked at. It’s doing too much rn
Dh even won snupys 2s tournament.
Needs more nerfs for sure
Yea one of the lowest rep classes over 2200 whats your point hunter?
well I’m not trying to be toxic ether but your advice is cheeks and thats bullsht if you have a hpal they literally just tunnel vision the hpal and no amount of slows or peeling gets them off on top of them basically double aoe cleaving everything. on top of you assuming im running ret pal war which im not a ape not running that running turbo and thunder theres no stun besides me and obviously my hpal shares dr with me.
we’ll need a zoologist to determine whether this disqualifies you from apehood.
ay yo im a zoologist
that guy aint a zoo, gonna need an apeologist to sort that out
i’ll accept wow gold or conq capping an alt 
I have 20 warriors I’m a certified ape, but I’m not ape enough to run ret warrior. The most ape comp out there is fw/ret/war the people that play that might aswell be full gorilla. im also just realizing half this thread is efc trying to defend his broken spec nice.
Maybe I’m a scrub, or just don’t run across good DHs on my lock, but DHs don’t bother me too much. I think they’re a little overtuned, but at least they have the decency to actually die when they’re supposed to. Maybe I’m just used to fighting DHs from back in BFA, too, but sub feels way worse to fight. Control. Burst. Tankiness, pick two, not all 3.
Sounds like it’s a bad matchup. Not demon hunters fault, a lot of comps can run down your healer.
I didn’t assume you were playing ret war either, where did you get that from? An turbo is more braindead than ret war so chill on the insults.
Turbo - lulz me click blood lust and purge go brrrrr